The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[pipër]

got this trade for 'em wondering if it's fair ? thanks '

[dakotapaws]

and this one?

[pigeon.enthusiast]

Should I accept?

Um, maybe?? I dont like rats that much but its double very rare so

Please only give educated advice! Maybe doesn't really help. Anyway, I would say no. You could get higher demand rares for the dragon, which would be more than the rabbit and rat.

Alright. Anyone else?

[todoroki shouto]

Should I accept?

Personally I think it isn't quite fair. Even though the bunny is a 09 vr , rats don't have the best demand. but its up to you!

got this trade for 'em wondering if it's fair ? thanks '

Demand wise it is unfair. Your little dragon cat is high in demand. It goes for much more.

[dakotapaws]

and this one?

[Shadow2204]

Should I accept?

Um, maybe?? I dont like rats that much but its double very rare so

Please only give educated advice! Maybe doesn't really help. Anyway, I would say no. You could get higher demand rares for the dragon, which would be more than the rabbit and rat.

Agreed with Clayflower. I've seen dragons go for more bulk. Both pets don't really have the greatest demand and the rat usually goes for half it's value.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58617081&userid=28347&signature=4JksMaz9-XekGLCQaadzcA

I don't know much about store pets, is this fair? ^^ Thanks :)
guess I was skipped. Anyone know if this is fair?

in my opinion they should replace the uncommons with the some rares for it to be fair for me but im really bad at trading so
also the store pets honestly dont seem fair..

If you don't know your rarities or not experienced at trading, it would be best for you to not answer in this thread, it would allow users to avoid confusion.
No, the trade is very unfair to you. The store pets are worth a late 2010 rare each, both of them would be able to get one of your dogs, the rest of the trade is barely worth half of one dog. So you're overpaying by roughly two 2009 rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58625948&userid=548495&signature=o_pxR_8GcfKePOZftbehEQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 91DM7hT9Fw

Should I accept any of them?

1. Store pps dragon cat is worth a late 2009 rare, but gets overpay of a few-bulk '09 rares. However, demand varies from person to person. The dragon goes for a small bulk of '09 rares as well and personally, I think it has about the same demand as the dragon cat (probably less). I've seen it go for a little bit more in auctions though.
To me, I see that trade as pretty fair since I love dragons. Though, this all depends on you.

2. I'd say the first one is more fair than this one. Rarity wise, this one is fair too, though, just an FYI, the rare sitting cat isn't a warrior so it goes for zero to slight overpay.

[kököchin]

Should I accept?

Um, maybe?? I dont like rats that much but its double very rare so

[left][size=85]Please only give educated advice! Maybe doesn't really help. Anyway, I would say no. You could get higher demand rares for the dragon, which would be more than the rabbit and rat.

I would have to agree with Clayflower
Malk dragons have high demand
They can bring more than what you were offered :3

[decembuary;]

i don't know how much of a demand the zodiac dogs have (not much) but i have a feeling this isn't that fair?

i'm terribly sorry - i won this dog from a giveaway, and a cake dog i have was also gifted to me - i have never had much interaction with high demand/list pets, so i'm fairly new to rarities ;w;
any thoughts on this trade?

[Shadow2204]

and this one?

The robo cat is worth an early '10 rare and could easily get a '09 rare (sorry for the repeat)
They are offering a mid '10 rare which is unfair, though, the other pets on the side makes up for the months, which makes it just about fair. although i still think the previous trades are better.

i don't know how much of a demand the zodiac dogs have (not much) but i have a feeling this isn't that fair?

i'm terribly sorry - i won this dog from a giveaway, and a cake dog i have was also gifted to me - i have never had much interaction with high demand/list pets, so i'm fairly new to rarities ;w;
any thoughts on this trade?

No, quite unfair. Zodiac dogs goes for a mid '09 rare most of the time and they are only offering a pet of lower value (months are off).
I don't know about what you meant about the list/high demand pets statement, i think you forgot to link the trade? Edit your previous post if so.

[Black.Wings]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58672829&userid=770728&signature=0kGw29Q2jtLEO5knKGYN9Q

So wish I could have my own thread and personal helper