The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[twozier]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JVZCuCbB7Q

would this be fair?

[LLHBBB]

Is this fair? - They said I should add but - uhm - I can't afford it- ahah- So. - umhhhhH- What should I add?

I believe it's already fair. Maybe a bit of overpay on your side

Technically it's unfair to them. The winged blood dog is a september list.

You would need to add about a Scarf PPS from the Sept list. Generally the punk dogs go for 7th tier advents from what I have seen.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58657535&userid=663291&signature=K8DBYwI03cqiJVZCuCbB7Q

would this be fair?

Your pet is a 2nd tier Advent and worth 4-5 Mixed 09 Rares so I'd say your asking way more than it's worth. You would need to remove all the store pets.

[LeSueur]

Hello, I have been trying to get opinions on this trade since yesterday, could anyone please help me? Thanks so much!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... s_o58aaLig

[Kaiiba]

Is this fair?

♥ Thank you to anyone who answers ♥

[Vlad Dracula III]

Is this fair?

♥ Thank you to anyone who answers ♥

Extremely unfair to u their pets maybe cover the halo but not the two main lists ( correct me if I'm wrong that is the 08 halo yes?)

[karachi]

Is this fair?

♥ Thank you to anyone who answers ♥

Extremely unfair to u their pets maybe cover the halo but not the two main lists ( correct me if I'm wrong that is the 08 halo yes?)

I agree. They are making you overpay. The halo does cover those two pets, but the two mainlists is just overpay for it all. I would just cancel it or ask them to add or remove the two mainlists.

[doggo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58653812&userid=559358&signature=pyytbh8k4cnfAKkDzrF2aw
would this be fair? c:
thank you! i would like a reply fast please this is for a bid <3

[reaptherisk]

**please PM me the answer, as it will be most convenient for me. (I still check the topic though) I will still say thank you and post your answer on the topic! **

Which trade is the best for my toxic lion? I've been told it's worth two 2009 rares.
1.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NsW9XxQ91A
2.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sDsWTvoavA
3.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7eKi-q-IJA


Thank you!!

Thank you so much LLHBBB!

Lions do tend to have good demand but I don't know that they are worth 2 '09 rares. The 1st trade is overpay based on rarities and amount of pets but fish are not the most popular. The other lion is from the same advent event as your so worth the same amount so the items are a bonus so it would come down to which one you prefer with that trade.

Second opinion?

[LLHBBB]

Is this fair?

♥ Thank you to anyone who answers ♥

Extremely unfair to u their pets maybe cover the halo but not the two main lists ( correct me if I'm wrong that is the 08 halo yes?)

I agree. They are making you overpay. The halo does cover those two pets, but the two mainlists is just overpay for it all. I would just cancel it or ask them to add or remove the two mainlists.

with the demand of the liontail which can go for extreme overpay the apple alone would be overpay on it's own & the most I would offer. Remove the grapes and the '08 halo.

[doggo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AKkDzrF2aw
would this be fair? c:
thank you! i would like a reply fast please this is for a bid <3