The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[turtle...]

how is this? unfair to any of the sides? I have never traded with cs dollars before ;n; any help is appreciated!!

[lupophobia]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

A lot. '16 store pets go for about a '10 rare while their side is only like an early '15 rare or something

Okay, how much do they need to add?

Your pet is worth a late-mid '10 rare. They need to add about 2 '11 rares OR an appropriate-age (mid-late) '10 rare

[Kabuski]

Hey guys so I sent this trade a while back and I was in love with the orange punk dog! So I was just wondering if this was a fair trade or not and whether the punk dogs' demand have increased or decreased as the months went on! Thanks;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wxTvMY7aMQ

Koka

For those who don't wanna click the link; 75 C$=1 punk dog?

Its unfair to the punk dog rarity wise since 7th tier advent lists go for 75$

[Heavenly paws]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

A lot. '16 store pets go for about a '10 rare while their side is only like an early '15 rare or something

Okay, how much do they need to add?

Your pet is worth a late-mid '10 rare. They need to add about 2 '11 rares OR an appropriate-age (mid-late) '10 rare

Thank you!

[Original.I.Am]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

A lot. '16 store pets go for about a '10 rare while their side is only like an early '15 rare or something

Okay, how much do they need to add?

I'd say about 3-5 '13-'16 rares I think, but get a second opinion please~

[Heavenly paws]

What do either of us need to add to make this fair? Or is it already fair?

[Original.I.Am]

Hey was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YnqN5c5T3w
I just wanna make sure, cause the dog I gave them was my first ever good pet XD
Thanks~

[turtle...]

how is this? unfair to any of the sides? I have never traded with cs dollars before ;n; any help is appreciated!!

[Quackers <3]

What should I add to make this fair? Thanks!

[Stranger Things]

Hey guys so I sent this trade a while back and I was in love with the orange punk dog! So I was just wondering if this was a fair trade or not and whether the punk dogs' demand have increased or decreased as the months went on! Thanks;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wxTvMY7aMQ

Koka

For those who don't wanna click the link; 75 C$=1 punk dog?

Its unfair to the punk dog rarity wise since 7th tier advent lists go for 75$

Accually its fair to both sides. If you look on the "how much is this worth in chicken dollars?" Thread it says a tier 5 (punk dog) is worth 75 chicken dollars.