The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[leonastefani]

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58601519&userid=322734&signature=-7y3QGeNDMSZDHi9grjsPg
They said they would be fine with bulks (since I don't have 2012/2010 pets on their wishlist) and I can add more items or pets. Thanks! (I'd also like to get at least two opinions, if that's okay.)

[Silverstar]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

Quite unfair to you, a '16 store pet is worth a late '10 rare.

[Stranger Things]

Okay i am so confused with this trade:

Someone said it adds up to 2 mid advents even thoughthey have 2 tier 7 advents
Someone said he coraline pps is worth 200 chicken dollars which i certainly dont believe is true
Someone said they were over trading
Someone said thye were under trading by a lot

So im confused. Could someone explain please?!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uA2w0927pQ

[kököchin]

Hey guys so I sent this trade a while back and I was in love with the orange punk dog! So I was just wondering if this was a fair trade or not and whether the punk dogs' demand have increased or decreased as the months went on! Thanks;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wxTvMY7aMQ

Koka

For those who don't wanna click the link; 75 C$=1 punk dog?

[Original.I.Am]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

A lot. '16 store pets go for about a '10 rare while their side is only like an early '15 rare or something

[MyNiallBear]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58621439&userid=400351&signature=WEs9s6qSQLe2EydP4zAKOw
Fair?

Can someone please answer?

[Heavenly paws]

I know this is unfair, please don't tell me it is unfair. What do they need to add?

A lot. '16 store pets go for about a '10 rare while their side is only like an early '15 rare or something

Okay, how much do they need to add?

[Original.I.Am]

Hey was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YnqN5c5T3w
I just wanna make sure, cause the dog I gave them was my first ever good pet XD
Thanks~

[Stranger Things]

Okay i am so confused with this trade:

Someone said it adds up to 2 mid advents even thoughthey have 2 tier 7 advents
Someone said he coraline pps is worth 200 chicken dollars which i certainly dont believe is true
Someone said they were over trading
Someone said thye were under trading by a lot

So im confused. Could someone explain please?!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uA2w0927pQ

[/quote]

[Quackers <3]

What should I add to make this fair? Thanks!