look please closed!

[Castiel Winchester]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

[bear]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

The light leo is worth Red Dragon & Early '09 Rare Dog, so generally it is worth 2 Mid Advents and Early '09 Rare Dog or Low&High Advent and Early '09 Rare Dog. So really to make the fair trade you'd have to remove the grown white scarf dog and replace it with an early '09 rare dog^^.

[Castiel Winchester]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

The light leo is worth Red Dragon & Early '09 Rare Dog, so generally it is worth 2 Mid Advents and Early '09 Rare Dog or Low&High Advent and Early '09 Rare Dog. So really to make the fair trade you'd have to remove the grown white scarf dog and replace it with an early '09 rare dog^^.

But their 2 list pets are not mid advents (tier 7s), and I have always seen tier 5 advents traded as being valued at 6 2009 rares. I have seriously never seen anything other than a tier seven considered a mid advent except for grouping purposes sometimes, and I've been trading lists for a mighty good chunk of time.

[Imabox]

How fair is this to either of our sides? There is a lot of pets with demand on their side so I just wanted to see if it was overpay with demand or technically still overpay on the Bee's side. Which if it is unfair to the Bee that is fine by me.

I had one person say it was still unfair to the Bee would need to add a Red Toxic or Sorbet. I just wanted to get a second opinion ^^

[bear]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

The light leo is worth Red Dragon & Early '09 Rare Dog, so generally it is worth 2 Mid Advents and Early '09 Rare Dog or Low&High Advent and Early '09 Rare Dog. So really to make the fair trade you'd have to remove the grown white scarf dog and replace it with an early '09 rare dog^^.

But their 2 list pets are not mid advents (tier 7s), and I have always seen tier 5 advents traded as being valued at 6 2009 rares. I have seriously never seen anything other than a tier seven considered a mid advent except for grouping purposes sometimes, and I've been trading lists for a mighty good chunk of time.

I always considered tiers 5, 6 & 7 to be mid advents, mostly because of this post where those two list pets they're offering on the "peppermint eared" tier is considered "Mid Advents" (well, they sit under that title).

[todoroki shouto]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ib0N7KELFA

[AdNuminousNot]

For One:
1: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=57675469&userid=795238&signature=2RXzQ-2GVdJWXNd-OLQf_Q

For Both:
1: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=57578828&userid=795238&signature=SdkGLS5pTsg8gw1CdpPGZA - Leading
2: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=57769047&userid=795238&signature=Vp4r-BTCrhYpAbgg_5Z86A
3: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=57778581&userid=795238&signature=MqteT996vyA1LfFiNLOhdg

I'm hoping to end my auction soon and was hoping to get a bit more advice. I have the first bid for both in the lead, does that seem right? Would it be a fair trade? I'm not sure I'm going to get any more bids but don't want to get less than they're worth. )
Thanks for any help!

[zenzi]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

The light leo is worth Red Dragon & Early '09 Rare Dog, so generally it is worth 2 Mid Advents and Early '09 Rare Dog or Low&High Advent and Early '09 Rare Dog. So really to make the fair trade you'd have to remove the grown white scarf dog and replace it with an early '09 rare dog^^.

But their 2 list pets are not mid advents (tier 7s), and I have always seen tier 5 advents traded as being valued at 6 2009 rares. I have seriously never seen anything other than a tier seven considered a mid advent except for grouping purposes sometimes, and I've been trading lists for a mighty good chunk of time.

people tend to round pets up rather then be very precise with their list pets. 5th - 7th tiers in general are just rounded up to 7th tiers. the light leo is worth 15 - 17 '09 rares depending on the pets. yes, by exact value this trade is fair, but as i said people would rather round up then add in the little bits. personally i would trade both 5th tiers plus an extra '09 rare

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ib0N7KELFA

unfair to you value wise, but personally i would consider this a good deal on both sides.
the rose set can defo fetch more then its worth value wise, personally i've had an easy time swapping the set with sorbets or a little lower. the bengal also has good demand and goes for overpay from time to time.

[Spoopy Season]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kBPUgQDtmw

Freaking out because there are too many pets :X
Thanks in advance!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Just to clarify...
I'm not confused, correct? The Light leo is worth 2 mid advents and a 2009 rare (15 mid advents)
Thier pets are worth 6, 6, and 3 (15 mid advents)
Rarity wise, this is perfectly fair, right?? They're telling me they were over-paying because my leo is only worth 2 advents..

The light leo is worth Red Dragon & Early '09 Rare Dog, so generally it is worth 2 Mid Advents and Early '09 Rare Dog or Low&High Advent and Early '09 Rare Dog. So really to make the fair trade you'd have to remove the grown white scarf dog and replace it with an early '09 rare dog^^.

But their 2 list pets are not mid advents (tier 7s), and I have always seen tier 5 advents traded as being valued at 6 2009 rares. I have seriously never seen anything other than a tier seven considered a mid advent except for grouping purposes sometimes, and I've been trading lists for a mighty good chunk of time.

5-7th tier are considered mid advents. So not just 7th tier. In all my years, I have always considered those three tiers to be mid advents and many people I work with do too. When trading list pets for other list pets, we don't use the 09 rare break down very much because thats very percise. Yes its worth 14-15 09 rares, but that comes from the 7th tier worth. Thats more like an unofficial value, and its more common for it to be seen as two mid advents plus some
Anyways just the two 5th tier advents and an 09 rare should be enough