Sorry, can't do the items part, but i could do the pets :)
Spotted tribal bun is worth about 6-7 Mixed 09 Rares + an 09 Uncommon, but it has pretty bad demand so i'd say about 4-5 2009 rares worth. The zodiac is worth about 3 2009 rare with demand.
Their malk mutant is only worth about a couple of 2009 rares (so i could equal to zodiac). And in total, they have three 2009 rares left which is a bit underpay for the spotted tribal.
Personally, i wouldn't accept just because you could get a higher underpay for the bunny if you try hard. The zodiac you could auction and get maybe a tiny bit more.
xStarLover wrote:Would this be fair or should I just not trade my store pets?
That's unfair to you. The store pets are worth about a 2010 rare each but they are only offer a 2012 rare + a 2014 rare which is unfair to even one of your pets.
The Lost Wilderness wrote:http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=56987503&userid=809304&signature=Mj8x7vYeYLHXNDyOoTmiHg
Is this fair factoring demand?
Store pets are a 2010 rare each so the set is worth two 2009 rares + a 2010 rare.
Each of the 2012 store pets are worth a 2009 rare, and the sitting cat is a rerelease from 2009 so it's overpay with just those three pets on their side. It's a pretty good trade