closed, go new thread!

[sluiceway]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51869647&userid=730109&signature=GHJti9x8omqc3nNkGrg5-w

I know this is a pretty bad trade but i just wanna know why there trading a rare for my cat

They might just really want the Valentine's cat. If someone is desperate to get something then they might overpay
imo I'd do it, since even if the cat turned rare (which seems unlikely), it'd still be overpay on their part

[linkin]

REPOST
More than one opinion, please.


one
two
three
four
five

The fourth one is the only one that I'm sure is fair. I don't know much about list pets, the light leopard/toxic bun would be my first one, should I accept.
I'd like to know which trade I get the most for what they're asking for.

[MaineiacJay]

Is this fair? Thanks!

[infinitestarsx]

is this fair?

just got this.

[sluiceway]

REPOST
More than one opinion, please.

one
two
three
four
five

The fourth one is the only one that I'm sure is fair. I don't know much about list pets, the light leopard/toxic bun would be my first one, should I accept.
I'd like to know which trade I get the most for what they're asking for.

All except 2 and 3 are unfair to you. Early '11 store pets go for 2+ '09 rares.
2 is fair/slight overpay on their side. 3 is overpay by like a low advent

4 is unfair to you since your store pet is older and worth more

[swallows]

REPOST
More than one opinion, please.

one
two
three
four
five

The fourth one is the only one that I'm sure is fair. I don't know much about list pets, the light leopard/toxic bun would be my first one, should I accept.
I'd like to know which trade I get the most for what they're asking for.

All except 2 and 3 are unfair to you. Early '11 store pets go for 2+ '09 rares.
2 is fair/slight overpay on their side. 3 is overpay by like a low advent

4 is unfair to you since your store pet is older and worth more

What would need to be added to the 5th trade to make it fair?

[blathma;;]

is this fair?

just got this.

I'd also like to know as the second trade with the Main List rat is mine.

[linkin]

REPOST
More than one opinion, please.

one
two
three
four
five

The fourth one is the only one that I'm sure is fair. I don't know much about list pets, the light leopard/toxic bun would be my first one, should I accept.
I'd like to know which trade I get the most for what they're asking for.

All except 2 and 3 are unfair to you. Early '11 store pets go for 2+ '09 rares.
2 is fair/slight overpay on their side. 3 is overpay by like a low advent

4 is unfair to you since your store pet is older and worth more

Thank you! I didn't realise that I read the date wrong for the fourth offer.
Which is worth more, 2 or 3?

And, yes, I'm curious about swallows' question as well.

[Remilia Scarlet]

what is a fair trade for the raven dog? Because of its stupid demand its literally IMPOSSIBLE to get it unless yoou extremely overpay.


i try trading a 4th tier advent, sept llist, target dog and cake dog and full carousel horse set and many early rares but i keep getting cancled because of the demandsd of my pets are crap. I really need help because the Raven is the ONLY pet i really really need and want but NOBODY will trade one. makes me wonder how the hoarders get them. Not fair at all

[Lacuna]

what is a fair trade for the raven dog? Because of its stupid demand its literally IMPOSSIBLE to get it unless yoou extremely overpay.


i try trading a 4th tier advent, sept llist, target dog and cake dog and full carousel horse set and many early rares but i keep getting cancled because of the demandsd of my pets are crap. I really need help because the Raven is the ONLY pet i really really need and want but NOBODY will trade one. makes me wonder how the hoarders get them. Not fair at all

Demand incorporated, the Raven is typically worth a Sorbet.

is this fair?

just got this.

I'd also like to know as the second trade with the Main List rat is mine.