closed, go new thread!

[Remilia Scarlet]

would this be a fair trade for the full set of Carousel horses?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SPxZgOXsMA

[The White Hart]

Hello again!

Is this a fair-ish trade? Click me!

[agust]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Of0hfz_I1g

Either I've overlooked an entire list of this person is very silly.. How fair is this?

[Vulpey]

Fair or Unfair to me?

They said the Dinos are worth a midadvent, and the items add up to 28 2009 Rares making this fair. Just want to double check c:

The dinos are most definitely not worth a mid advent. They are worth a mid '10 rare, but with demand may go for late '09s. They may be attempting to scam you.

That could be reasonable. I've only had lists since about October/November. And the Dinos are in huge demand. Second opinion? I'm pretty sure 23 09 Rares doesn't even equal a Mainlist.

[Shadow2204]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51707103&userid=94687&signature=lfDaFjN3IlkfOf0hfz_I1g

Either I've overlooked an entire list of this person is very silly.. How fair is this?

Very unfair to you, the green october dog isn't high in demand and it's not a list so definitely unfair to you

[agust]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51707103&userid=94687&signature=lfDaFjN3IlkfOf0hfz_I1g

Either I've overlooked an entire list of this person is very silly.. How fair is this?

Very unfair to you, the green october dog isn't high in demand and it's not a list so definitely unfair to you

Okay I thought I was loosing my marbles for a while there. Thank you.

[swallows]

Fair or Unfair to me?

They said the Dinos are worth a midadvent, and the items add up to 28 2009 Rares making this fair. Just want to double check c:

The dinos are most definitely not worth a mid advent. They are worth a mid '10 rare, but with demand may go for late '09s. They may be attempting to scam you.

That could be reasonable. I've only had lists since about October/November. And the Dinos are in huge demand. Second opinion? I'm pretty sure 23 09 Rares doesn't even equal a Mainlist.

They do have a GWJ, but I'd agree that it is unfair to you. demand wise and rarity wise.

[The White Hart]

Hello again!

Is this a fair-ish trade? Click me!

[Reki.]

Fair?

[Shadow2204]

Fair or Unfair to me?

They said the Dinos are worth a midadvent, and the items add up to 28 2009 Rares making this fair. Just want to double check c:

The dinos are most definitely not worth a mid advent. They are worth a mid '10 rare, but with demand may go for late '09s. They may be attempting to scam you.

That could be reasonable. I've only had lists since about October/November. And the Dinos are in huge demand. Second opinion? I'm pretty sure 23 09 Rares doesn't even equal a Mainlist.[/quote]

Demand for the dinos will go down pretty soon (maybe a month later). Like gracie said, don't think it's worth that much. And yea, I'm pretty sure 23 '09 rares doesn't equal to a mainlist. I think it would be worth a few advents.

Irrelevant fun fact:
I would decline b/c I don't like having the knowledge that the UR peach = UR hollydog