The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Constellation.]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance

unfair to you

Please provide a reason as to why it's unfair, as stated in the rules
Also, I cannot view your trade link for some reason, Sans? it takes me to a weird search website.
EDIT: now the link doesn't work at all. Very strange!

The other user who replied must have accidentally deleted a letter from the link, because it pulls up as "Could not find an address for "chicknsmoothie.com". Previous page has the correct link.

[Horror]

BMD + ??? = Lime Ice Rat

[stress]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51029723&userid=751273&signature=Hnd7FUzLzZoPxqw8eX-esA
Was this fair? I'm pretty sure they were overpaying on their part, I got the scarf for a android. But I'm still not sure....

And yes, I think they are overpaying too. Lovely trade though!

thank you!

[steakems]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance :D

[~Rainy Days~]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance

I believe its unfair to you Rarity wise, seeing how the UNickorn is above the gap, however its demand is terrible so this might be a good offer for it. I feel like this is one of those pets you really have to decide yourself if you are ok with it. It might be hard to get a fair trade for it of good demand pets.

[o u t f o x e d]

Is this fair? Does the UR Malk has SUPER bad demand or something?

[misted]

Is this fair? Does the UR Malk has SUPER bad demand or something?

Actually the UR malk has really good demand. Idk if this is fair though.

[o u t f o x e d]

Is this fair? Does the UR Malk has SUPER bad demand or something?

Actually the UR malk has really good demand. Idk if this is fair though.

OH okay! Thanks!


Any opinions?

[agust]

Is this fair? Thanks! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1wDOIQ_DHA

[o u t f o x e d]

Is this fair? Thanks! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1wDOIQ_DHA

Pretty sure unfair to you, because of the dates. There aren't enough commons to match the 2012 uncommon dates.