The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Frankina]

Grevy's Zebra = July PPS? Demand wise? Thanks!
And what would be added to the July PPS to trade for a UR Tiger?

Not bad for the zebra when considering demand,
it is rarely traded for its true list value.
For the UR Tiger you'd need to add 3 more nons worth
as the tiger is worth 5 by rarity alone. With demand, it can
easily fetch 8+ non overpay.

[steakems]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance :D

[o u t f o x e d]

Fair??

[skywishes01]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51027277&userid=677898&signature=dVayytOh_QdJHsTgJ19xlA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -1nGQUZUXA


I feel like both of these are quite fair but want to make sure
Thank you for the advice

yup, definitely fair if not overpay on their part- the PPS dragon kitty is worth about an 09 rare, maybe more with it's demand. but those trades are definitely fair

[jayxras]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance

unfair to you

[ShadowStarFang]

Hello!
Negotiating through this trade and I'm now starting to think I am overpaying. Help please? Thank you!
Meow!
I really don't want to trade the rare draft horse from 09, but I wanted to see if removing it would be fair or not.

[Shinobi's Lamina]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JcKC1xXizQ
Is this fair?
Thank you in advance

[SureinDragon]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance

unfair to you

Please provide a reason as to why it's unfair, as stated in the rules
Also, I cannot view your trade link for some reason, Sans? it takes me to a weird search website.
EDIT: now the link doesn't work at all. Very strange!

[stress]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xqw8eX-esA
Was this fair? I'm pretty sure they were overpaying on their part, I got the scarf for a android. But I'm still not sure....

[piggie]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance

unfair to you

Please provide a reason as to why it's unfair, as stated in the rules
Also, I cannot view your trade link for some reason, Sans? it takes me to a weird search website.

Same here. I am unable to access the link.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51032502&userid=677898&signature=Zei1u9ZF0Fc3JcKC1xXizQ
Is this fair?
Thank you in advance

This is very unfair to you. The wolf PPS is at the bottom of the mainlist- but is still on! The pets and items added do not add up for your pet.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51029723&userid=751273&signature=Hnd7FUzLzZoPxqw8eX-esA
Was this fair? I'm pretty sure they were overpaying on their part, I got the scarf for a android. But I'm still not sure....

And yes, I think they are overpaying too. Lovely trade though!