The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[ImThatRogue]

This fair http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w2ak-HMKyA

This could either be fair or unfair, depending on what the rarity of the dogs turn out to be. I believe every 2-3 Hannukah '14 coins is worth a '14 vc or so, so all of their items together would be worth about a '14 common. If your dogs turn out to be common, it'd be a fair trade. If they turn out to be very common, it's unfair to them by a '15 common. If they turn out to be uncommon, it's unfair to you by a '14 common + '14 very common.

What does my partner need to add? Here is the trade, thanks for any help!
x

Without taking into account the demand of their pets, their side adds up to be worth only a bit more than 4 '09 rares. Therefore, they'd have to add a bit more than a scarf pps in order for this to be fair. However, their warrior cats and malk dragon seem to have some demand, and can go for more than they're worth.

Hello! I'd like to know if this trade is fair: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51030910&userid=370219&signature=66bhbEXZx1b6L2gBO6Q_Hg

This is technically a fair trade. Both pets seem to have good demand, and often go for more than they're worth. However, I believe the shima has a bit more demand than the May lioness. Ultimately, demand is user based, so it's up to how you and your trading partner value the pets.

[WesternWolf2528]

Hey everyone! I was wondering if this trade is fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aIfPCIEOfw
If it isn't, what needs to be added to make it fair? Thanks for your time.

Unfair to you by about a line tribal.

Thank you for your advice! Any others?

[stress]

Hey everyone! I was wondering if this trade is fair:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aIfPCIEOfw
If it isn't, what needs to be added to make it fair? Thanks for your time.

Unfair to you by about a line tribal.

__+__=Pink balloon? Would any of these pets work? Wolf pps, rose pps, and What should I add to make it fair for a purple toxic or yellow toxic?

A balloon dog is worth about 2 low mainlists (20-21 mid advents, so the wolf pps (worth 10 mid advents) + rose pps (11 mid advents) would be fair enough. The gap between the balloon dog and the yellow toxic is another balloon dog (although the yellow toxic seems to have some demand), and the gap between the balloon dog and the purple toxic is about a CEG tier.

Pink balloon + ? = nonballoon?

What could be added to close up the gap? Thank you for any opinions!

Roughly a skelly pps.

Clockwork bunny + ? = target dog
thank you in advance!

Strict rarity wise (without taking demand into account), the clockwork bunny is worth 4 '09 rares and an '09 uncommon or so. The target dog is worth about 16 '09 rares. Therefore, a low September would have to be added.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QbtJ1HlvVg
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y6o46saWpg
Either of those fair?

1. Depending on whether or not your dog grows up to be the vr or r outcome, this could be either unfair to them or unfair to you. If your dog turns out to be rare, then just the first rare dog would be enough. However, if your dog turns out to be very rare, then it would be unfair to you by a couple '09 commons or so, I believe.

2. Unfair to them, no matter what outcome your dog grows up to be. Each of their pets is an '09 rare, and your dog would be worth, at most, 2 '09 rares.

2010 uncommon ying yang lion = 2010 uncommon wave malk cat?
Demand included?

In my opinion, both lions and malk cats have the same demand. However, that may be just me. I value them the same, but others may see if differently. Demand is ultimately based on user opinion, so it changes from person to person. It's ultimately up to you and your trading partner. However, depending on what month the pets are from, it could be fair or unfair.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51029502&userid=725835&signature=MU3LDkISXPwqcP_juSjmkg


is this fair to my side with the dragon?

Strictly rarity wise, this fair to me. The purple sleipnir is a 1st tier advent worth 3 '09 rares, so your 3 rares should be fine for the sleipnir. That rat is a mid '10 re-release, so that's a fair swap for your store pet. However, the purple sleipnir seems to have some demand. But at the same time, so does your malk dragon.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51030226&userid=660207&signature=ioQS8vN9TieVRZ6yE9KRCw
Fair for my Sunjewel bun? If not, what do they need to add?

And this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xmBWiH0lDA

1. Unfair to you. Their side adds up to be worth about a scarf pps, so a low September list pet would have to be added for it to be fair.

2. Also unfair to you. Their side adds up to about a pink striped september, so another mid advent would have to be added in order for it to be fair. Your sunjewel bun is worth 5 mid advents.

Oh sorry, thanks!

[ShadowStarFang]

Hello!
Negotiating through this trade and I'm now starting to think I am overpaying. Help please? Thank you!
Meow!
I really don't want to trade the rare draft horse from 09, but I wanted to see if removing it would be fair or not.

[Guest]

Hello! I'd like to know if this trade is fair: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51030910&userid=370219&signature=66bhbEXZx1b6L2gBO6Q_Hg

[pechaberrie]

Please help! Which is better for my August PPS? ;-;

This

OR

This Plus this

[Pragmatic]

What should I do to make this fair? Thank you in advance!

[steakems]

Is this a good trade? I really need some opinions on it ^D^
Rarity wise and Demand-wise if possible! Thanks in advance :D

[ontari]

What are UR foals currently going for? Could I get a UR banana?

[Rocka_Boo]

is this pretty much fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p3fUQPLutA