The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Blackbirds]

Please tell me if this trade isFair or not! Thank you!

[legendari]

is this trade fair? C: thank you in advance, I really appreciate all advice!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qDywHI0ukw

Without taking into account the demand of their store pet, you're overpaying. Just your tess horse alone would be worth almost 2x the value of their store pet since their store pet is worth a '10 rare and your tess horse is an '08 re-release available for an extended amount of time into '09. However, their store dragon seems to have some demand and can go for overpay.

thank you! c:

[ImThatRogue]

__+__=Pink balloon? Would any of these pets work? Wolf pps, rose pps, and What should I add to make it fair for a purple toxic or yellow toxic?

I answered this on the 2 pages back.

Please tell me if this trade isFair or not! Thank you!

Quite unfair to you. Your UR mint horse is an above-gap list pet worth 2 sorbets and a red rose. The gap between the black advent and the UR mint is about a spotted tribal. However, the black advent does have good demand and often goes for much more than it's worth. Even so, I personally value the black advent at about a sorbet, so the UR mint is a bit much... However, demand is ultimately user based, and it's up to you and your trading partner to decide how you value your pets. But rarity wise, this is very unfair to you.

[agust]

Hello! Can someone help me out please? Is this a fair trade? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uWED48EA8g

[Raccoontail66]

This fair http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... w2ak-HMKyA

Second opinion...

[ImThatRogue]

Hello! Can someone help me out please? Is this a fair trade? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uWED48EA8g

Quite unfair to you. Your bunny is the UR butterbun, a main list pet worth much, much more than that. Their side barely even makes a dent in the value of the butterbun. They'd still have to add about a butterbun in order for it to be fair.

[agust]

Hello! Can someone help me out please? Is this a fair trade? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... uWED48EA8g

Quite unfair to you. Your bunny is the UR butterbun, a main list pet worth much, much more than that. Their side barely even makes a dent in the value of the butterbun. They'd still have to add about a butterbun in order for it to be fair.

Thank you very much, I wasn't sure weather or not it was!!! <3

[Blackbirds]

__+__=Pink balloon? Would any of these pets work? Wolf pps, rose pps, and What should I add to make it fair for a purple toxic or yellow toxic?

I answered this on the 2 pages back.

Please tell me if this trade isFair or not! Thank you!

Quite unfair to you. Your UR mint horse is an above-gap list pet worth 2 sorbets and a red rose. The gap between the black advent and the UR mint is about a spotted tribal. However, the black advent does have good demand and often goes for much more than it's worth. Even so, I personally value the black advent at about a sorbet, so the UR mint is a bit much... However, demand is ultimately user based, and it's up to you and your trading partner to decide how you value your pets. But rarity wise, this is very unfair to you.

Thank you so much! Can I please have a second opinion?

[Kittycentral~]

What does my partner need to add? Here is the trade, thanks for any help!
x

[Guest]

Hello! I'd like to know if this trade is fair: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=51030910&userid=370219&signature=66bhbEXZx1b6L2gBO6Q_Hg