The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Fussy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=50995379&userid=764918&signature=THcdF86MrTVMMai6nYr1yQ

Unsure if this is fair? Seen a few people with the PPS as dreamies and was wondering if the demand for it was somewhat higher?

If anything it would be unfair to them. I don't think the ghost PPS has more demand than usual.

Thank you!

Any second opinions?

[piggie]

Is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UDiWpjQr0A

VERY Unfair to you. Warrior cats have a high demand, are from older years and do not add up to last years store pets.

[Kittycentral~]

I got an offer with a pink sorbet for my UR grapes. Fair rarity and demand wise? Does the pink sorbet have good demand?

[Guineapigsrule1306]

Is this fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UDiWpjQr0A

VERY Unfair to you. Warrior cats have a high demand, are from older years and do not add up to last years store pets.

Thank you for your help

[swallows]

Would this be an ok offer on a tigerdog?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=50994850&userid=293211&signature=G8KEX_lxHfoPCHb7HY7FvQ

Still unfair to the tiger dog. The pineapple is the only pet with a high value. You need to add more listies in the high tiers of september list/ low of main list.

Not true, there is a pink sorbet.
Second opinion please?

[lrjj]

I got an offer with a pink sorbet for my UR grapes. Fair rarity and demand wise? Does the pink sorbet have good demand?

Rarity wise it's a tier swap so fair
Demand wise whilst grapes have "low demand"
They actually often trade fairly
In fact I traded the UR grapes for a sorbet before they were actually moved up to the sorbet line
So I'd definitely say fair

[p e a c h y]

Can I get some opinions?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=50995648&userid=598743&signature=wCrUEWTlwWL4S5T21_BcEQ

Thanks in advance! <3

[Frankina]

I got an offer with a pink sorbet for my UR grapes. Fair rarity and demand wise? Does the pink sorbet have good demand?

Rarity wise it's a tier swap so fair
Demand wise whilst grapes have "low demand"
They actually often trade fairly
In fact I traded the UR grapes for a sorbet before they were actually moved up to the sorbet line
So I'd definitely say fair

The UR Grapes do seem to trade well.
I agree, it's a fair offer and sorbets have good
demand too^^

[koth]

Can I get some opinions?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=50995648&userid=598743&signature=wCrUEWTlwWL4S5T21_BcEQ

Thanks in advance! <3

I think they need to add two balloon dogs and a red X PPS to make it fair.

[Kittycentral~]

I got an offer with a pink sorbet for my UR grapes. Fair rarity and demand wise? Does the pink sorbet have good demand?

Rarity wise it's a tier swap so fair
Demand wise whilst grapes have "low demand"
They actually often trade fairly
In fact I traded the UR grapes for a sorbet before they were actually moved up to the sorbet line
So I'd definitely say fair

The UR Grapes do seem to trade well.
I agree, it's a fair offer and sorbets have good
demand too^^

Thanks so much guys! Could they go for more perhaps?