closed! go to new thread!

[Shadowflight13]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AniUKtHaJQ
If not what should be added? (to either side)

Also, what about this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xDA9Qe-vIQ

[HarukiChan]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Eq9By0-SzQ
I need help please and thanks
could you pm me the response plz so I get it

[zoloft]

Is this fair

[lrjj]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Eq9By0-SzQ
I need help please and thanks

Unfair to them

Your side adds up to just over two sorbets
Whereas their side equals 4 sorbets (non + sorbet)

So you'd need to add two sorbets and remove the other pets
Or
Add a sorbet and something on the tier below

[Dexah]

Hi ^^

Could anyone help me to which of these bids is more fair for the 7th tier advent list VR Tag Husky?

Bid 1
Bid 2

Really would apreciate the help! Thank you in advance! <3

[fūi]

demand wise,

Coontail for Orange cerb + raven + marionette? Does coontail have good demand lately?

[Kyar]

Decided to post the trades for my sunback pup here. They all look like overpay to me, but I wanted to know what more experienced players have to say:

First
Second
Third
Fourth (I'm 90% certain this is a dogtag.)
Fifth
And someone else is offering either a Grevy or Plains Zebra.

I hate leaving people I'm trading with hanging, so it'd be really cool if someone could help me out soon.

I want to start this by saying, get multiple opinions!
I value the sunback (with demand) to be around 3 nons.
So bid 2 would be an underpay. Bid 3 is an overpay, however both URBWolf and rat have poor demand.
Bid 1 seems to be an overpay if you ask me (joker and BEG are each at least a non, plus crazy high demand advent and sept list pets)
Bid 1 is certainly my favorite, but get another opinion because I'm kind of biased when it comes to every pet in that bid lol

1. Of course it depends on how you value the pets but with a joker at a non (pretty standard) and the quantity of high demand store pets (I'd say they could get a sorbet easy considering all demand factors) plus the BEG where it sits at list placement… it'd be roughly fair. High demand for high demand often cancels out but considering the quantity of demand on their side I'd call it a solid offer that really doesn't benefit either side THAT much - it seems like a pretty good trade in my opinion.
2. A bit unfair to you rarity wise and demand doesn't make up for it. I wouldn't recommend this offer.
3. Overpay for certain but as noted the BW is a bit hard to trade due to its very high value. It has decent demand but it's not enough to bring in many offers and few people can afford it. The rat isn't high demand but trades off reasonably fairly with some time. Value wise it's worth nearly a moonswirl so almost double the sunback's list placement.
4. A very common offer for a sunback. It's a good solid overpay and it's something I do see happen quite a bit. This would probably get you a bit more ahead of the first offer but demand is always hard to say - it's possible the first could get you more but it might not. This is a good safe and solid offer.
5. Not worth quite as much as the dogtag but it's another pretty decent offer. The coontail has pretty good demand though the GWJ can be a bit tougher.

All in all I'd recommend either 1 or 4 depending on what you're going for. :)

Edit:

demand wise,

Coontail for Orange cerb + raven + marionette? Does coontail have good demand lately?

Definitely unfair to the coontail. Those pets have high demand but the coontail has good/average demand if not a little higher than average so I wouldn't recommend it. The value difference is immense.

[liv :)]

I got this trade recently.

I'm pretty sure they are overpaying, but not certain. Since they are offering a lot of unknown rarities from this year, I'm a bit confused as to whether or not this is an overpaying trade. I'm assuming the OMG so common is what makes me think it's unfair to them. Opinions, please?

[Power On]

EDIT AGAIN

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Fh1pi5Lbjg

I know the cucoon isn't the VR PPS because it's too old

Please count demand too

THANK YOU :3 PLEASE ANSWER

OR PM

Pretty Please?

[zoloft]

Is this fair