Do not post, go to new thread!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

It was my opinion i said it in my message that it might be false. and i do learn and i did not answer alot back there because i did not know. why always take the pressure on me?

If you are unsure if the trade is fair or not don't post advice about it. I am not being rude but you have posted a lot of false advice and it is honestly not fair. People keep getting scammed due to getting the wrong advice and it is not fair. If you don't know about a trade don't post advice about it ^^

Ok fine if you know so much about trades than will this be fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5To9G9-Slg

Puppet never claimed to be great at giving advice. They were simply telling you not to give advice if you aren't sure. If you have to say "I may be wrong" you probably shouldn't be giving advice

That trade is unfair to you. They need to add 2-3 2010 uncommons to be fair since they are only offering a tad over a 2010 rare. Which isn't enough for your 09 rare

[Valerie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vnIRImBOXQ

Is this fair rarity and demand wise?

[Just_pixels]

I need some help on some trades i got for my auction? Are any worth accepting?

1

2

3

4

5

Any help is appreciated, may take more then one opinion

[Sharp Glimpse]

Is this fair? Thank you for any help!

[Kyar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=49914269&userid=546456&signature=OaM7TjvxOFwYvnIRImBOXQ

Is this fair rarity and demand wise?

They're overpaying quite a lot in terms of rarity. I'd certainly say that's more than enough to account for demand too. All in all - I'd call it unfair to them.

I need some help on some trades i got for my auction? Are any worth accepting?

1

2

3

4

5

Any help is appreciated, may take more then one opinion

1. Unfair to you in terms of rarity - the non list pets really don't make any real difference to the value of their side. They're basically offering you the toxic 1:1 for the mint horse.
2. Very unfair to you - definitely not as good an offer as the toxic (trade 1).
3. It has a touch more quantity but it's still unfair to you and still not worth as much as the purple toxic offer.
4. Extremely unfair to you - their side isn't even worth half of the horse and while they do have some quantity none of their pets are very high demand. I would strongly advise against this offer even if you want to get quantity out of the horse.
5. Ridiculously unfair to you - the raven dog has great demand but it's not even remotely close to worth that much. Unless you're dying to have one immediately and that's the only pet you have to offer I wouldn't even give that trade a second glance.

[Lighinz]

I'm not sure if these are fair. If it's not, What should be added/removed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -ZD-Z2NwLQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... b_EJZi2_Tw

Can i have some help with these?

[Kyar]

Is this fair? Thank you for any help!

Unfair to them by quite a lot - the C$ items on their side are worth more than the wings on their own and the 2010 shadow creature is a pretty tough to find and sought after item.

I'm not sure if these are fair. If it's not, What should be added/removed?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -ZD-Z2NwLQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... b_EJZi2_Tw

Can i have some help with these?

1. Unfair to you - the bat is worth about 3-4 2015 uncommons or a 2013 uncommon from around the same time of year.
2. I'm not the best with quantity for uncommons across years but I'm almost 100% positive that's unfair to you. They're offering pretty recent and low value pets compared to yours - I don't think they have enough on their side to bridge the value and year gaps.

[whitedane]

Is this fair?

[Føxxi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vWVs4dW19w

Is that a fair trade?

[WeWe]

i think your yellow wolf is a 2008 rerealese. well thats my opinion. but i would probably accept the trade

P.S dont say im giving false advice because this is for what i will do if i had that trade!

I think that it is unfair to them (And please do correct me if i'm wrong). The yellow sorbet is a main list, but so is the ballon dog. They are offer a september list as well,
so they may even be overpaying.

Last time I checked the Ballon dog was 7 tier on main list while my sorbet is 15 tier. I just want to know if other pets cover the gap since I'm not quite sure about how much advent and spetember list are worth.

The trade I got is linked below. I'd really like to get advice if this is fair and not some false advice... Thanks
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lDJo9fFbUA