The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

is this fair?

As always with unknown rarities, it's hard to say for sure. However it looks very unfair to you, even considering the big gap in years.

The 2011 is worth more than 2015 pets. Always.

If all the pets are common (maybe one as an uncommon) it looks about fair since the 2011 very common adds up to being worth roughly a late 2013 uncommon
It just depends on the final rarities

[MintyDragon]

Bump

[DaDwarf]

New thread!

Go here!

Please no marking and such.

[Saddened]

Ur hollywing + ? = non coon
.
Please what would be fair?
Pm.me.please to if you'd like the thread seems to get faster XD

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OHNbfDClGA
This fair as well?
It think its unfair to me but by how much, and what should they add?

The gap is a green toxic so that's what they would need to add

But the trade at the bottom?
Any opinions?

[Stickss]

is this a fair trade... ?






the top three for the warriors sitting cat (blackstar)

[avanhellica]

is this a fair trade... ?






the top three for the warriors sitting cat (blackstar)

very unfair to the cat. the cat is a '08 rare and the
pets offered do not add up to be the equivalence
of the feline, if I believe so. i also believe they have
fairly decent demand as well. may want a 2nd opinion ^^

[Eternal Flame]

I Know I'm Asking A Lot But I Need More Help x.x Click Me For First Bid I Own The Non Tag And Current Best Bid Is A Raver Bun and A UR Pickle

Also No Idea If Any Of These Are List Pets I Dont Think They Are Click Here For Other Bid

Would Love Some Help Rating Them Against My Top Bid Rated at 9.2/10 As Well :3

the gap between a gwj and a non is a red toxic by rarity, not mentioning the gwj's horrible demand
personally i'd rate that somewhere around a six or a seven.
a ur pickle is overpay by rarity but is struggling to get fair trades, or a single above the gap pet.
five or a six for that one.
the third doesn't even add up to a mainlist.

Thanks I'll Add That One And Consider Changing The Pickle's Trade Anyone Else Have Ideas About The Pickle's/Gwj Ratings? Im Trying To Get A Overall Good Bid Thing Without Making Anyone Mad That The Rating's Changing So Much (Sorry This Is My Second Auction Ever So Ratings Are Still Hard For Me)

[DaDwarf]

New thread!

Go here!

Please no marking and such.

[PuppetxChild]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=49588410&userid=748687&signature=vIB6LlxLpWlc8JZf3xP1LQ

Is this fair? if not why isn't fair/ what needs to be add/removed. I'm not good with items .-.

not sure if anyone answered this for me...

[IQuit;;]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QCI-rPiukw