The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Eternal Flame]

I Know I'm Asking A Lot But I Need More Help x.x Click Me For First Bid I Own The Non Tag And Current Best Bid Is A Raver Bun and A UR Pickle

Also No Idea If Any Of These Are List Pets I Dont Think They Are Click Here For Other Bid

Would Love Some Help Rating Them Against My Top Bid Rated at 9.2/10 As Well :3

the gap between a gwj and a non is a red toxic by rarity, not mentioning the gwj's horrible demand
personally i'd rate that somewhere around a six or a seven.
a ur pickle is overpay by rarity but is struggling to get fair trades, or a single above the gap pet.
five or a six for that one.
the third doesn't even add up to a mainlist.

Thanks I'll Add That One And Consider Changing The Pickle's Trade Anyone Else Have Ideas About The Pickle's/Gwj Ratings? Im Trying To Get A Overall Good Bid Thing Without Making Anyone Mad That The Rating's Changing So Much (Sorry This Is My Second Auction Ever So Ratings Are Still Hard For Me)

[dwarjam]

is this trade fair?
if not, how should I edit it.

also, I prefer to trade the pets on my side as a whole set.

Please, don't give false advice. If you do not know what items are worth, just don't say anything.
The 08 Halo is worth an low septemberlist, each one of the fairies an 09 rare.
I'd even say it's overpay on their side

thank you! :>

may I have a 2nd opinion? I just want to be entirely sure and not regret the trade later. u v u

[Queen~of~Crows]

is this trade fair?
if not, how should I edit it.

also, I prefer to trade the pets on my side as a whole set.

i dont think that trade is fair their just items little fairys for your rare pets/very rare pets i advise you to decline it doesnt seem that fair

I Believe that that halo is worth a low september list pet and each malk fairy is worth a mid-ate 09 rare each.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

is this trade fair?
if not, how should I edit it.

also, I prefer to trade the pets on my side as a whole set.

i dont think that trade is fair their just items little fairys for your rare pets/very rare pets i advise you to decline it doesnt seem that fair :thumbdown:

I Believe that that halo is worth a low september list pet and each malk fairy is worth a mid-ate 09 rare each.

If you're valuing the halo at a low September, it's roughly a fair trade
If you are valuing it higher, like I do, it's unfair to them ^^

[BraveEguana]

Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GYzqi1Jjvg

yes thats fair if its a store pet then its fair if its not still fair 70 Cicken dollars wow! can you tell me their username? i think i might wanna offer for their chicken dollars

I don't really know what you want to say, so it's like 10 C$ overpay. A 2nd tier Advent list is worth around 60 C$.

[Topiratti]

Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GYzqi1Jjvg

yes thats fair if its a store pet then its fair if its not still fair 70 Cicken dollars wow! can you tell me their username? i think i might wanna offer for their chicken dollars

It's unfair to the player offering the 70C$, the roadkill pony is worth 60C$. Please don't give advice unless you are sure that you are correct.

[onion]

is this trade fair to the bottom?

[Just_pixels]

I disagree with this due to the demand of dragons. iv been offered two or three 2009s for my red dragon and even then the player was willing to add

Was This fair?
Thanks in advance!

Unfair to them ^^ the dragon is only worth 30-35C$

[Saddened]

]Ur hollywing + ? = non coon
.
Please what would be fair?
Pm.me.please to if you'd like the thread seems to get faster XD

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OHNbfDClGA
This fair as well?
It think its unfair to me but by how much, and what should they add?

[whitetail deer]

Fair? c: