The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[FelisUrbanus]

Wow, really?
Had no idea they were worth that much! I must be lucky then, because those are both my spares
Thank you both so much for telling me this! <3
Maybe the person who offered the trade saw my post, because they cancelled it not long after I posted here

I'll be sure to save these guys up then!

Caution! I said that's what I'd been offered and had accepted, they are not worth that much! The demand can go far beyond the worth during the event, but after the event demand will drop and the real worth will emerge, which is much much lower!

[Sharp Glimpse]

Is this fair? Thanks!

Also was this fair?

and

UR Bengal + ??? = Blue Toxic

[ahirked]

Wow, really?
Had no idea they were worth that much! I must be lucky then, because those are both my spares
Thank you both so much for telling me this! <3
Maybe the person who offered the trade saw my post, because they cancelled it not long after I posted here

I'll be sure to save these guys up then!

Also note that not all banner pets are rare. Take last year's Halloween banner dog for example - it turned out to be Uncommon.

On the topic of banner pets, I am not sure what to do about this: x

[..thunder..]

Can I get 2013 store pet for my 20 C$?)

No, you'd need to add more C$ as it's older. This would belong better on the 'What is my pet worth in C$' thread, and not here.

[FelisUrbanus]

Hello ^^ I haven't been on in many months (at least, not on enough to trade anything else than monthlies) and am very fuzzy on Advent List trading, not that I was at any time apt at it anyway xD

So, I received this trade.
It looks to me, at first glance, like overpay: same tier Advent, yet all sorts of random recent wishlist pets tacked on.

The thing is, even though I really want those store lions, I don't like that Nick Cake, never have. The bunch of pets is, after all, just icing and sprinkles in this trade offer.
Furthermore, correct me if I'm wrong, but that pet seems very hard to trade... and what I wanted to do with that Tufted Blood dog, one day, is trade up.

All that to say... I'd like an opinion, is this a fair trade?

[NB: and is the Nick Cake harder to trade than the Tufted...]


Thanks alot ^^

from my personal experience, i traded my nick cake quite easily, though i hear a lot of other users have trouble
the blood dog would be easier to trade away, but i don't think it's that big of a demand difference
also the lions and dragon are quite popular right now
(personally i would take it, however i recommend getting a second opinion though)

Thank you ^^

Can I get a second opinion please?

[Sali]

Is this fair, or should I add something more?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yThgRXlh5A

Thanks for any help

[Mommy Amon]

Is this fair? Thanks!

[Lilabounce]

Time for another post!

Got this suggestion from someone, is it fair?

[cchimp123]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Qvjdflin5Q

[..thunder..]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Qvjdflin5Q

I'd say it's unfair to them since their uncommons are older, but it's pretty much fair. (Unless the items hold significance, I'm not good with items)