The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[kurimu]

item trades, I can't value them

also what's the brown border collie + candy cane bwolf + red string horse equal to? would I be a September or am I too far off?

[sluiceway]

I NEED HALP.
Which one would be more fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tbzV4sQs6w

or this one? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 28Ia1VTJkg

Okay, I'm not positive as to how much but this trade is wicked unfair to the dark leopard. His on the tip their of the September and width more than what they are both offering.

i agree, just want to say that that's the light leo, not the dark leo

item trades, I can't value them

also what's the brown border collie + candy cane bwolf + red string horse equal to? would I be a September or am I too far off?

unfair to you, the quiver alone is worth a early '09 rare, which is overpay for their side

by rarity, a target dog

Hello ^^ I haven't been on in many months (at least, not on enough to trade anything else than monthlies) and am very fuzzy on Advent List trading, not that I was at any time apt at it anyway xD

So, I received this trade.
It looks to me, at first glance, like overpay: same tier Advent, yet all sorts of random recent wishlist pets tacked on.

The thing is, even though I really want those store lions, I don't like that Nick Cake, never have. The bunch of pets is, after all, just icing and sprinkles in this trade offer.
Furthermore, correct me if I'm wrong, but that pet seems very hard to trade... and what I wanted to do with that Tufted Blood dog, one day, is trade up.

All that to say... I'd like an opinion, is this a fair trade?

[NB: and is the Nick Cake harder to trade than the Tufted...]


Thanks alot ^^

from my personal experience, i traded my nick cake quite easily, though i hear a lot of other users have trouble
the blood dog would be easier to trade away, but i don't think it's that big of a demand difference
also the lions and dragon are quite popular right now
(personally i would take it, however i recommend getting a second opinion though)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=49111119&userid=243043&signature=bjs7_Tgfp_f9R4bfB8eJVw

Is this fair? Thank you. If not, can you please explain what I did wrong?

unfair to you, the store pets would be about a fair swap (perhaps slightly unfair to them)

Fair? If unfair, how should it be modified?

Thanks in advance!

unfair to you, the ice crown is worth a late '10 uc and it alone is overpay for their side
lunar flowers are a few mid '13 c each

while their items are all from late '13 onwards

[KumyaKuma]

Is this trade fair? I am unsure how much my draft horse is worth compared to those store pets.

[Ironic Equation]

also what's the brown border collie + candy cane bwolf + red string horse equal to? would I be a September or am I too far off?

Hmm, with the tess horse demand I would say a high advent to grinner

[sluiceway]

Is this trade fair? I am unsure how much my draft horse is worth compared to those store pets.

by rarity, this is unfair to you by another '15 store pet, or late '10 rare
though the draft horses don't have great demand, while the store deer do from what i've seen

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

I NEED HALP.
Which one would be more fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tbzV4sQs6w

or this one? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 28Ia1VTJkg

The first one is very unfair to the light leo. Their normal rares do not make a sept list at all (:
The second, looks much better, but it's slightly unfair to you still ^^

You are correct in the first
However the second is unfair to the top. The Royal bun plus 7-8 09 rares would be fair

[ʟᴏʟʙɪᴛ]

Is this fair?

[redpineapple1]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IxOLKk48Eg
Not good with items at all. Help?

This one too
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nf_qyZYvzQ

[ʟᴏʟʙɪᴛ]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=49120756&userid=64280&signature=QEIe68K9cigHIxOLKk48Eg
Not good with items at all. Help?

This one too
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nf_qyZYvzQ

First one - Unfair to you, your items are older and worth more than their recent pets
Not sure about the second one

[MunchiiMoon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=49120756&userid=64280&signature=QEIe68K9cigHIxOLKk48Eg
Not good with items at all. Help?

This one too
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nf_qyZYvzQ

First one - Unfair to you, your items are older and worth more than their recent pets
Not sure about the second one

Second one is unfair to them, each of their vr dogs is worth 2 of yours