The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[The White Hart]

Could I get some quick advice on these trades? These are all trades offered to me by other people.

Trade 1: 2 2009 ponies for some bunnies:
I am a trade!

Trade 2: Cherry Blossom Dog (store pet) for a collection of owls (2009-20012)
I am also a trade!

Trade 3: 2009 rats, spiders, and 2015 staff pets for a bunch of dogs (mostly older staff pets)
Hi, I'm a trade, too!

[Constellation.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=48632393&userid=743165&signature=Hu065oKRkyfZC0hnv8Idag
Fair?

Very unfair to you, your pets are worth about 135 C$ total, if I'm not mistaken. ❤️

[Lyren]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=48631570&userid=692944&signature=igDtL7zdHBz-phBbisfr2w
Do i need to add another '10 uncommon? (Te dog is 2011 re-release)

[RippleEffect]

Which of these should I cancel?

Bid 3

Bid 6

Bid 8

Bid 9

Bid 12

Bid 15

Bid 16

Bid 18

Bid 19

Thank you

hewo?

[.holliday]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=48632582&userid=664401&signature=7l_ZqkvZpm3pfmrmEYQeCQ
Is this fair rarity and demand? Please specify both. If it's not what needs to be added to the trade? Thanks

[Paperd]

Could I get some quick advice on these trades? These are all trades offered to me by other people.

Trade 1: 2 2009 ponies for some bunnies:
I am a trade!

Trade 2: Cherry Blossom Dog (store pet) for a collection of owls (2009-20012)
I am also a trade!

Trade 3: 2009 rats, spiders, and 2015 staff pets for a bunch of dogs (mostly older staff pets)
Hi, I'm a trade, too!

1. Unfair to them. One of the ponies would cover both bunnies, although how you value bunnies is up to you

2. I believe unfair to them. The storepet is valued at 2010 rare and I believe those owls do not equal that. I could be wrong though, so second opinion is good idea

3. Again, unfair to them. However, many people do not like rats, and value their staff pets a lot. Either way it's a great deal if you do not mind rats and spiders demand


I personally would not accept 1 and 3 cause I do not like rats, but I would accept 2

Which of these should I cancel?

Bid 3

Bid 6

Bid 8

Bid 9

Bid 12

Bid 15

Bid 16

Bid 18

Bid 19

Thank you

hewo?

I personally would cancel bid 6 as the 2009 rare they are offering isn't a real warrior cat. The other bids have decent pets they are willing to give in my opinion. You could cancel bid 15 if you don't like fish or bunnies as some people really don't like them

[Princess Taozi]

Which of these should I cancel?

Bid 3

Bid 6

Bid 8

Bid 9

Bid 12

Bid 15

Bid 16

Bid 18

Bid 19

Thank you

hewo?

I would cancel bid 3,6,15

[chicken of life]

Is This Fair?

[The White Hart]

Thank you, Paperd!

[InkaySquidd]

Is This Fair?

Unfair to them.
The purple toxic itself is fair for the green toxic