Since it seems like everyone's been going for all the hard ones, with lots of options, I thought I'd take a shot at guessing Saikiyo's pup since I feel like it's easier as there aren't that many options for their pup:
Hasn't grown yet (hint posted Sept 8 - day 7)- Narrows it down to 5 options; it has to be either a day 8 or day 9 pup and one of the day 9 ones is claimed by Lillian.
- It goes down to 4 options when considering that another of the day 9 pups has to be PitchBlack's (likely the bubble pup).
- A lot of people have been guessing the wip pup to be Chia's and their theories seem to make sense, and even if it's not hers I don't think it's Saikiyo's either.
Which leaves only the day 8 pups...
My outcome's green- First pup has green eyes.
- Not sure about middle one.
- Egg pup... uhh.... Green eggs and ham?? I really don't know x'D
Either blue base or orange base- The middle pup seems to be the one that's most obviously prominently orange, but the egg pup seems to also have an orange base ((there's a bit of blue on the shoulder that I can't tell if it's part of the egg shells or a marking)). And in my opinion the first pup has a blue base, but I don't know if others would count the orange bits as a marking or consider it a blue-and-orange base.
- However, it's possible that the hint only applies to the adult stage and if so then we'll have to wait and see how they turn out when they grow!
Says chicken smoothie on it- All three have the site tag on them but it's possible that the adult stages might have chicken smoothie written elsewhere on them. Either that or this is a troll hint.
((Though, I can't see the smoke on the middle pup clearly; the second curl looks like an "S" but the first one, it's a bit of a stretch but I can see it looking like "C" if you ignore the bottom part curling back to the body. Otherwise it just looks like "SS". Or maybe it'll say "CS" when the pup grows up??))
Never gonna make you long tail- None of them have a long tail, at least in my opinion. How long is long anyway? xD
- Middle pup has a round tail?
I'm leaning towards the egg pup being theirs at the moment, because after digging for a little I found some posts that the hints chart seemed to have missed out:
Hint: mine the one that has ___ ______ ((3 blanks; 6 blanks))
source ((their post is on the previous page but this one has the blanks count))
- What if...
egg shells? That has 3 letters and 6 letters.
- It could also be
(something) cracks or
(something) smokes which would make it apply to the middle pup, but I can't think of anything that fits the first part.
May or may not be a chickensource- Of course, it doesn't have to be specific to any outcome since if it's not a chicken then it can be anything but.. chicken hatch from eggs right, but while this is an egg pup it doesn't necessarily have to hatch into a chicken, so what if it's actually a hint that's more specific to the actual pup stage and not just a general hint?
There's also a bit more to the "never going to make you long tail" hint
in this post (it's in transparent text):
Never gonna give you up. Never gonna let you down. Never gonna run around and desert you. Never gonna make you long tail. Never gonna say goodbye. Never gonna tell a lie and hurt youFrom Rick Astley's Never Gonna Give You Up - I'm not familiar with that song but googling it, I found that "never gonna make you long tail" replaces the sentence "never gonna make you cry" in the song. Don't know if that's relevant/important? Maybe it relates to something about the meaning of the song or something in the music video?
Still leaning towards the egg pup at the moment though...
Of course, that's if I'm correctly in eliminating all of the day 9 pups. It's possible that theirs isn't even one of the day 8 ones. xD And assuming that the hint about not having grown by day 7 wasn't a lie.