The "Is This a Fair Trade" Thread

[Young and Beautiful]

X?

Rather unfair to them.

[♥ Konata ♥]

blue field dog + rare 2010 unicorn + long tailed black 2nd gen dog = 10 2011 staff + 11 2010 staff? havent sent trade yet

Please provide true name of the pets/Images. No one could know which rare 2010 unicorn you could be talking about

[Shvlby]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46215822&userid=450462&signature=9vJXbkrqaiBbjZKrUjixMQ
Is this a fair bid?

If i added this up correctly, yes this is fair. ^^

[BeautifulPoo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46215822&userid=450462&signature=9vJXbkrqaiBbjZKrUjixMQ
Is this a fair bid?

If i added this up correctly, yes this is fair. ^^

Thank you

[BeautifulPoo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sC-keVtNsA
Sorry but is this one fair as well?

[Kruxly]

im having a raven auction, i'd like info/individual opinions please

-Bid 4
-Bid 5
-Bid 9
-Bid 10
-Bid 11
-Bid 12
-Bid 13
Bid 17
Bid 18
sorry, its alot

The red cerb bid is the best bid 'demand' wise
Then the Wolf PPS bid
Then the green toxic bid
The TWA bid is the fairest bid in terms of the dogs actual worth (without demand) its still overpay but you have higher offers

--------------

...

Honestly.. I regret this trade.. Was it fair? ):

Too much overpay for the August PPS, the android would have been my limit if i wanted to overpay. The PPS is still only worth a 2012 very rare.


-----------------

X?

unfair to the dog

[LLHBBB]

what would need to be added to this to make it a fair trade? Both rarity and demand wise.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... InQKHrqglw

To make it fair to the dog you need to remove everything but the 3 09 rares

to make it fair to the bottom, 2 09 rares need to be added atleast.. (needs a second opinion)

Actually no. The dog is worth 3-4 09 rares.

thanks for both of the replies. The 1 dog plushie is worth an '09 rare so I just wanted to be sure I wasn't not offering enough because I sent the offer and they sent it back saying they wanted more because their dog was worth more.

[Kruxly]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46215789&userid=450462&signature=sRJZXxwiXjfvsC-keVtNsA
Sorry but is this one fair as well?

unfair to the rat. The dog and deer add up to a 2009 rare

[BlankRedColor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3toOh-K_gQ

Is this fair?

[LissaJo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46215888&userid=182352&signature=iDaFxIlztnQH3toOh-K_gQ

Is this fair?

not fair.. the 2015s only add up to a 2015 common