please use new thread!

[Ashki]

So, I sent this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45431141&userid=298301&signature=PpZk1Cs5sPLC2JBvDWX6yw


They cancelled with the mesage "Not fair at all" and then I PMed them asking how it wasn't fair and they replied with this:

Because if you look at the date.
Also those are malks, so they are worth about 4 or 5 times more than anything with that same rarity and date except for Nicks.

Is that true? Are Malks worth more? Was the trade I sent really unfair? Thanks!

Malks are not worth any more than normal pets. ^^ The pets on your side were enough for theirs, the items were adding overpay. However, a lot of people do like malks. This does not make them worth anywhere near to 4-5 times their value though.

[♥ fefetasprxte ♥]

So, I sent this trade:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45431141&userid=298301&signature=PpZk1Cs5sPLC2JBvDWX6yw


They cancelled with the mesage "Not fair at all" and then I PMed them asking how it wasn't fair and they replied with this:

Because if you look at the date.
Also those are malks, so they are worth about 4 or 5 times more than anything with that same rarity and date except for Nicks.

Is that true? Are Malks worth more? Was the trade I sent really unfair? Thanks!

the trade was quite fair ^.^ if not overpay
they are quite wrong. though malks have demand, they are worth no more than a pet within three months of eachother with the same rarity (unless on the list of course)

[Kyar]

Thank you, Blaine, for the help.

Now, was this trade fair as well? (Warning: Huge quantity trade.)

How many pets did they give you? And as far as I saw none were above uncommon - correct?
I'd say it looks reasonable or maybe a bit unfair to you - it's hard for me to gauge exactly how many pets there were but the 09 VR is worth some serious quantity of newer pets. So. At a glance it looks decent to me but again I can't be totally sure how many they gave you without counting lol.

[Party Poison.]

UR Ice Cat + Blood PPS + Emerald Butterflywolf = Nonballoon + ???
also,
UR Ice Cat = Pink/Blue Balloon + ???

[Streak]

Thank you, Blaine, for the help.

Now, was this trade fair as well? (Warning: Huge quantity trade.)

How many pets did they give you? And as far as I saw none were above uncommon - correct?
I'd say it looks reasonable or maybe a bit unfair to you - it's hard for me to gauge exactly how many pets there were but the 09 VR is worth some serious quantity of newer pets. So. At a glance it looks decent to me but again I can't be totally sure how many they gave you without counting lol.

I rounded around 600 and most were very common, maybe about 5/8 Very Common 2/8 Common and 1/8 Uncommon so I'd agree somewhere along the lines of slightly unfair to you since the pets are from '13 and '14 but may be fair, most people don't do bulks for rares because of rares value, just saying c:

[3000feet]

hello is this fair? Thanks guys!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4v1wyj8k0Q

[LuckyHeart]

hello is this fair? Thanks guys!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4v1wyj8k0Q

unfair to you; 10 C$ is worth a '10 uncommon

[kenobi]

Is a 2009-04-03 Malk rare tan wolf worth a shima long?

[Party Poison.]

hello :D is this fair? Thanks guys!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4v1wyj8k0Q

Unfair to you, a late '09 rare is worth C$25-30 c:

UR Ice Cat + Blood PPS + Emerald Butterflywolf = Nonballoon + ???
also,
UR Ice Cat = Pink/Blue Balloon + ???

[zenzi]

UR Ice Cat + Blood PPS + Emerald Butterflywolf = Nonballoon + ???
also,
UR Ice Cat = Pink/Blue Balloon + ???

The first gap is about 3 Mid advents (get a second opinion) and the second gap is a Grey Malk dragon. ^^