use new thread!

[ImThatRogue]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45177456&userid=703939&signature=Pe21_Vl83iiXawTaA9nvnQ

What should I do with this trade? Is the blue ice rat hard to trade off?

Do whatever you want to do with the trade, but it is really unfair to them.
Rats typically are hard to trade off, but with that said; if you find the right person you will get the rat's worth with ease.
If you want to find out more, browse the auction threads / trade threads and see what they go for.
It's unfair by approx a grinner.

Thanks so much for the help! However, may I get another opinion on whether or not I should accept this trade? I understand that rats seem to be very hard to trade off, and I'd like more opinions from experienced users (since I don't have any experience with list trades).

[tawnypelt3]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45177456&userid=703939&signature=Pe21_Vl83iiXawTaA9nvnQ

What should I do with this trade? Is the blue ice rat hard to trade off?

Do whatever you want to do with the trade, but it is really unfair to them.
Rats typically are hard to trade off, but with that said; if you find the right person you will get the rat's worth with ease.
If you want to find out more, browse the auction threads / trade threads and see what they go for.
It's unfair by approx a grinner.

Thanks so much for the help! However, may I get another opinion on whether or not I should accept this trade? I understand that rats seem to be very hard to trade off, and I'd like more opinions from experienced users (since I don't have any experience with list trades).

If you want to keep the rat, then it might be in your interest to accept the trade. If you would trade it off, probably better not to accept. Then there's always the question of morality with trades; does the other person know they are overpaying, and are they okay with that? If they're okay with overpaying then you only have to consider whether you'd prefer the difficulty of trading the rat off fairly or for overpay. If they aren't aware that it's overpay and you accept the trade, it's called "ninja trading" and while not against the rules, is greatly frowned upon since it makes people feel bad to get ripped off.

Please remember to post a trade only once per page. You can give feedback or make a different post more than once per page, but for the same trade, just once.

[Zelda the Wolf]

I'm offering:
2012 VR
2014 VR
2009 VR
For a:
Kiss PPS

Is it fair?

[QuirkCirc]

I'm offering:
2012 VR
2014 VR
2009 VR
For a:
Kiss PPS

Is it fair?

Depends on which pets your offering. Some pets have better demand than other pets with the same rank and year.

[Goostarion]

I'm offering:
2012 VR
2014 VR
2009 VR
For a:
Kiss PPS

Is it fair?

Depends on which pets your offering. Some pets have better demand than other pets with the same rank and year.

Unless the VR's from each year listed are rereleases from '09, it is unfair to the Kiss PPS; no matter what pet it is.

[QuirkCirc]

Thank you! I would like one more opinion <3!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8ux4eKRB7Q
Also this? (:![/quote]
Hmm...A good bunch of the items are from 2013 slumber party and some from the 2011 medical event. I think it would be a little (Not much) unfair to you, but I'm not positive *Sheepishly chuckles* Second opinion?

[Goostarion]

Thank you! I would like one more opinion <3!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8ux4eKRB7Q
Also this? (:!
Hmm...A good bunch of the items are from 2013 slumber party and some from the 2011 medical event. I think it would be a little (Not much) unfair to you, but I'm not positive *Sheepishly chuckles* Second opinion?

I do not know whom this is in reply to, but it is unfair to the items.

[~Vetra~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45181827&userid=661834&signature=4YUiZvT4TXXG64siAoCK7Q
can someone please tell me if this is fair?

[Takk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=45181827&userid=661834&signature=4YUiZvT4TXXG64siAoCK7Q
can someone please tell me if this is fair?

Unfair to them, the sitting cat had extended release and I don't think it's fair for the malk cat

[Zelda the Wolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nI43hh4h6A

Fair