The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Silverstar]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43945371&userid=689850&signature=z5BsOpTFY0HULWOQ9qWCxw

Unfair to them.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43945206&userid=516703&signature=0tIDKUhWGEJFn93QHtG_3Q
I have a gut feeling, but I need to confirm... unfair or not?

looks unfair to them actually, but not by much
the first 12 pets would be fair - they add up to 4 2014 uncommons, which is enough for the rare.

[ArgosKhaos]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ak-9hi0i4A

would this be fair

[Moonlightelf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43945206&userid=516703&signature=0tIDKUhWGEJFn93QHtG_3Q
I have a gut feeling, but I need to confirm... unfair or not?

Unfair to you. I imagine your gut feeling is correct.

looks unfair to them actually, but not by much

Oookay, thank you both.
May I please get third opinion? ^^'

[merriweather]

Red Toxic {Main} + BMD {September}+ Skeleton Rat {September}+ Line Tribal {Main} = UR Tiger Dog (?)
|
Is this fair? I'm willing to trade all of those pets for my DREAMIE the UR Tiger dog, plus almost any pets from my fodder group. If it's fair or I'm overpaying (or anything) is anyone here willing to do this? ~

Sadly no-where near, they together would be worth around a CE galaxy

...really? Did I take under pay for my cucumber then? I got all of the pets listed above for it other than fodder and the skeleton rat. And what trade would be fair for a UR tiger dog?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Red Toxic {Main} + BMD {September}+ Skeleton Rat {September}+ Line Tribal {Main} = UR Tiger Dog (?)
|
Is this fair? I'm willing to trade all of those pets for my DREAMIE the UR Tiger dog, plus almost any pets from my fodder group. If it's fair or I'm overpaying (or anything) is anyone here willing to do this? ~

Sadly no-where near, they together would be worth around a CE galaxy

...really? Did I take under pay for my cucumber then? I got all of the pets listed above for it other than fodder and the skeleton rat. And what trade would be fair for a UR tiger dog?

yes that was unfair to the cucumber
the tiger is worth 5 nons, which your side is worth a little less than half of one non

[merriweather]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43945621&userid=643199&signature=Xp9r-bVLQTuNAk-9hi0i4A

would this be fair

Your overpaying a little bit. A store pet is worth one 2010 (late) rare. And a VR isn't worth a 2009 rare + 2 other slightly more recent rares. ~

[newt.]

Is this trade fair? Demand wise?

Unfair to the Grevy's, even with demand

Thanks. May I get a second opinion please?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43945621&userid=643199&signature=Xp9r-bVLQTuNAk-9hi0i4A

would this be fair

Your overpaying a little bit. A store pet is worth one 2010 (late) rare. And a VR isn't worth a 2009 rare + 2 other slightly more recent rares. ~

not all store pets are worth 2010 rares and the one dog is a rerelease ^^
yes its unfair to the bottom though
the two 2010 rares would be fair for the very rare dog. The store pet is worth a mid-later 09 rare, so the two other 09s would be overpay for it

Is this trade fair? Demand wise?

Unfair to the Grevy's, even with demand

Thanks. May I get a second opinion please?

rarity wise its unfair to the zebra
demand wise ti doesn't seem bad. but demand is user based and can't be pin pointed exactly

[Alias Cassi Renn]

What can i add to the rat to make this fair?


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JCY0cudT3w


Thanks in advance!