The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[kamelgirl]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

Thank you! just wondering then would it be fair or unfair? and to which side, thank you [/quote]

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^

[Flossie]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

Thank you! just wondering then would it be fair or unfair? and to which side, thank you

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^[/quote]

True, it's unfair to the rat, but rats have horrible demand, while malk Dragons have high demand. It's your choice, but you could be stuck with the rat.

[kamelgirl]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^

True, it's unfair to the rat, but rats have horrible demand, while malk Dragons have high demand. It's your choice, but you could be stuck with the rat.

I don't know, the List takes demand AS WELL AS rarity into account. Just my opinion, but I think it's really unfair to the rat.

[invincible llama]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

Thank you! just wondering then would it be fair or unfair? and to which side, thank you

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^

True, it's unfair to the rat, but rats have horrible demand, while malk Dragons have high demand. It's your choice, but you could be stuck with the rat.[/quote]


But the rat is 8 tiers higher, which is a lot, and, like kamelgirl said, they do put demand into the list.

[KC.]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^

True, it's unfair to the rat, but rats have horrible demand, while malk Dragons have high demand. It's your choice, but you could be stuck with the rat.

Kamelgirl is correcrt the lists already take demand into account. Please do not give out advice on this thread, if you are not clear on the lists.

[Doctor.Who.]

2014 VR + 2009 butterfly wolf rare=2008 pps rare?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

2014 VR + 2009 butterfly wolf rare=2008 pps rare?

it depends on the specific pets, it would be better to show a trade or show the pets. or even use their correct names.
its likely fair, but it depends on the 2014 pet and the date of the butterwolf

[lucky333123]

]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

Thank you! just wondering then would it be fair or unfair? and to which side, thank you

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^[/quote]

True, it's unfair to the rat, but rats have horrible demand, while malk Dragons have high demand. It's your choice, but you could be stuck with the rat.[/quote]


But the rat is 8 tiers higher, which is a lot, and, like kamelgirl said, they do put demand into the list.[/quote]


The list does take demand into account, but members tend to add an "extra user demand" to pets.

Rarity wise unfair to the rat.
Demand wise, you are better off with the dragon since it is a lot easier to trade the dragon than the rat, but I would still say unfair to the rat because of the major difference of the placement of the two pets on the list.

[invincible llama]

Sorry for another question just been getting trades I'm not sure about, thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OgPsc-5lbQ

they added this message - 'hi! would this be ok?? my pet is higher on the list, so i hope its good overpay ^.^' I was just wondering what they are referring to as the 'list', this probably sounds really stupid, thank you.

Thank you! just wondering then would it be fair or unfair? and to which side, thank you

It's very unfair to the rat's side, since the rat is 8 tiers above your dragon ^^

But the rat is 8 tiers higher, which is a lot, and, like kamelgirl said, they do put demand into the list.[/quote]

I had a September list rat and it was VERY hard to trade away, I luckily traded it away along with most of my rares for a line tribal but it took 20+ other pets and 3 list pets.

[/quote]

It is unfair to the rat, 8 tiers is quite a lot.

[DaDwarf]

Please drop the subject, ele_elf_ele got plenty of advice now so there's no need to linger on about this trade. Thank you all.