The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[h e l l o]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UxnEQs2moQ
Was told pps was from 2009 but was told again that it was a rerelease.

[Cattusorb]

Is this fair? I think it's not, but I just wanted to double-check. ^^

Not fair, that's an '08 rare for a new store pet, I'd say you could get atleast 2-3 new store pets with that '08 rare.

[Sh4dowDr4gon]

Sooo i am in an auction and i think i am overpaying but i love the pet and love to have it, thank you looking forward to the help <3 thank you!!Xx
My bid: (all the links i have 2 add ons all for the malk)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2Ibs8axYbg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ke-MMo1OCQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xf-KD25ztA

[CaptainSpank]

Would this Trade be Fair?
My Trading Partner uses as a Rule: "2 UC = 1 UC + 2 C = 1 R", I thought it was more "3 UC = 2 UC + 3 C = 1 R"...?:

I kind of did an adding game (2 Uncommons or 1 Uncommon & 2 Commons = Rare for example) and this is about what I came up with. There really isn't a jump between the years like there is between 10' and 09' so there really shouldn't be a mass of pets to compensate.

What would be missing on which side otherwise...?
(Don't worry about the Items, they are fairly recent and not much worth, I reckon...)
Thanks already for any advice...

captain spank, that is an unfair trade

Don't accept those pets are worth more

Ah OK, Thanks already, but what is missing on their side, or what should I remove from my side...?

Any chance to get a precise Answer somebody, please, I started asking 2 hours ago and I only got half of an Answer...?
(And I need to leave soon...)

[Giulietta Capuleti]

Is this fair? I think it's not, but I just wanted to double-check. ^^

Not fair, that's an '08 rare for a new store pet, I'd say you could get atleast 2-3 new store pets with that '08 rare.

Thank you! ^_^

[мσƨƨғıяε]

Hi there~
Is this trade fair? If not, how could I make it fair?

[Joof]

How about this one? Is it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XVNdvInH1Q
Thanks for any help c:

[Cattusorb]

Hi there~
Is this trade fair? If not, how could I make it fair?

Not fair to you. That's a 2013 rare, there would need to be either and 2014 rare on their side or you can remove the rare for yours for an uncommon 2013?

I would always get a second opinion c:

[Immortal]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _Uf0ZxMgdg

[Onyxeva]

Would a Pink Stripe Sept + a Target Dog = a Red Rose Dog?

If not, what would need to be changed?