The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Wolf Tamer620]

Hi i'm holding an Auction and i would like to know whether this is fair
Trade
Thanks

[Snowy_Owl]

Hi i'm holding an Auction and i would like to know whether this is fair
Trade
Thanks

I think that's just fine, since the Drafts do not have a good demand. I would accept it

[little dragon's Mum]

Hi i'm holding an Auction and i would like to know whether this is fair
Trade
Thanks

I would say unfair to you - the Malk Cat is from February 09 and the Malk Smiley is from April 2010 with your VR Draft Horse from August 2009. The other pets don't quite cover the gap and I don't think the demand for the Draft Horses is too bad - it's certainly better than before they had old lineart. It's better than the other bid you've got for your auction.

[Giraffegirl13]

Help please :s Thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B7yNfjnjVA

[little dragon's Mum]

Help please :s Thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B7yNfjnjVA

I would say it's unfair to them - their rat is the light heart rat and is on the September List, alongside the BMD. There are no list pets on your side and I'm pretty sure that your pets added altogether, don't add up to their rat. In saying that, although it may be overpay, it is a rat and would be a little harder to trade off. I would get a second opinion.

[Giraffegirl13]

Help please :s Thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B7yNfjnjVA

I would say it's unfair to them - their rat is the light heart rat and is on the September List, alongside the BMD. There are no list pets on your side and I'm pretty sure that your pets added altogether, don't add up to their rat. In saying that, although it may be overpay, it is a rat and would be a little harder to trade off. I would get a second opinion.

ok thanks, other opinions? x

[.wren.]

Help please :s Thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B7yNfjnjVA

I would say it's unfair to them - their rat is the light heart rat and is on the September List, alongside the BMD. There are no list pets on your side and I'm pretty sure that your pets added altogether, don't add up to their rat. In saying that, although it may be overpay, it is a rat and would be a little harder to trade off. I would get a second opinion.

ok thanks, other opinions? x

[.wren.]

Help please :s Thanks

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... B7yNfjnjVA

I would say it's unfair to them - their rat is the light heart rat and is on the September List, alongside the BMD. There are no list pets on your side and I'm pretty sure that your pets added altogether, don't add up to their rat. In saying that, although it may be overpay, it is a rat and would be a little harder to trade off. I would get a second opinion.

ok thanks, other opinions? x

It's unfair to them as far as the List goes. But rats even on the lists have low demand. ^~^

[indebted]

-snip-

I would say it's unfair to them - their rat is the light heart rat and is on the September List, alongside the BMD. There are no list pets on your side and I'm pretty sure that your pets added altogether, don't add up to their rat. In saying that, although it may be overpay, it is a rat and would be a little harder to trade off. I would get a second opinion.

ok thanks, other opinions? x

It's unfair to them as far as the List goes. But rats even on the lists have low demand. ^~^

I don't think it particularly matters too much about demand in this circumstance. It's pretty unfair to them, since it's on the September List. Although it might be difficult to trade off, it's still massively unfair.

[sturmi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RzYbqE0g1A
I just got this ;n;
I dont really like to trade the items but Im wondering if this is fair