The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[PenguinQueen]

is this a good deal?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AG55eI3ZyQ
Thanks!

[Centri]

Is This Fair? Is The Dog Their Offering On The List?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43336532&userid=689850&signature=RkJiD-ENVIVqAyIE2lgjtg

Unfair to them, their dog is on the list. ^^

thank you! second opinion anyone?

Yep, unfair to them, no doubt.

[steakems]

Which bid should I accept? If you could give me opinions on all that would be great! <3
1
2
3
4
5

Thanks guys! One more opinion?

[~ lainey]

for a BMD.. fair?http://oi60.tinypic.com/208zj45.jpg

No. You should add at least a list pet. Plus their demand is pretty high.

That would be unfair to the BMD. And please just use the [share trade] link in the future. Seeing the trade without dates/rarities makes things harder.

guys, i need more info than that. what do i add? i don't have lists.
and i didn't use the share trade because i haven't sent it yet. i wanted to make it fair before sending it and you can very clearly see the dates/rarities of the things i am offering. the BMD is very rare (12/14/2008).

[Cony]

Is this fair?
If not by how much?

Thanks for any help!

Unfair to them by about a mid advent, you should get a second opinion.

Thank you for your input.
Second opinion?

[Alias Cassi Renn]

Is this fair?
If not by how much?

Thanks for any help!

Unfair to them by about a mid advent, you should get a second opinion.

Thank you for your input.
Second opinion?

Agreed, unfair to them

[~GirlsDeMo~]

Should I do it?? (09 UR Dog is in there))

Seeing as it's horribly unfair to the other person, I would ask to make sure they know what they're doing first. If they want to overpay massively, it's their choice, but I personally wouldn't give up a UR 09 dog for two Advents.

Second opinion?? and how is the demand of the 09 UR DogVSRaven Dog?

[Azahlea]

May I please get some advice on this trade?

Unfair to them. A mid advent is worth 7 2009 rares. A cake dog that isn't far below is worth 5 mid advents.

Thanks! About how far off am I? I was told a Purple Bat Dog is worth about 49 '09 rares, but I don't know how that translates to late 2008/early 2009 very rares.

[niceplant]

Should I do it?? (09 UR Dog is in there))

Seeing as it's horribly unfair to the other person, I would ask to make sure they know what they're doing first. If they want to overpay massively, it's their choice, but I personally wouldn't give up a UR 09 dog for two Advents.

Second opinion?? and how is the demand of the 09 UR DogVSRaven Dog?

unfair to the '09 UR either way

[~GirlsDeMo~]

May I please get some advice on this trade?

Unfair to them. A mid advent is worth 7 2009 rares. A cake dog that isn't far below is worth 5 mid advents.

Thanks! About how far off am I? I was told a Purple Bat Dog is worth about 49 '09 rares, but I don't know how that translates to late 2008/early 2009 very rares.

so doing my math

I value each 2009 VR Rat at Two 2009 rares each.. I counted 25 rats o.o

25 X 2= 50

So I would say unfair to you.. Get a second opinion


@anonymoose Alright!! Is it worth accepting??