The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[PenguinQueen]

Hi! Could I get an opinion on this?

Thanks!

unfair to the other side, their rare fish is a re-release from 2009

[miyadera]

Is this fair? What should I add on my side? Or should they add on their side.

[korok]

Hi! Could I get an opinion on this?

Thanks!

unfair to the other side, their rare fish is a re-release from 2009

However, them rainbow dogs can be really popular and fish aren't

[wonderfall-]

Hi, I have a BMD auction currently going on and I need help to place the leading bids.

~ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7oLp-nO5bg I just love love love the quantity and all the wishlist!! With all those pets, what list and what tier would it get?

~ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2UtPjbYxUQ I like this bid, but I've heard that apples have really really bad demand or something, so I'm not sure.

~ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NbAvSsf1bg This is also kindafrom the same person, but it's quite nice too and I didn't say people couldn't double bid so yeah, but what place should it be?

~ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2Qg-1cp72A This is a really nice bids too!! I love the blue Rose and the dragon!

Thanks in advance!

- LuckyDucky265

[little dragon's Mum]

Is this fair? What should I add on my side? Or should they add on their side.

Slightly unfair to them. Their lion is from Valentines 2009 and the dog from May 2009. You two sitting cats are from Christmas 2009 and the Warrior cat from September 2009.

[Dragonan]

if I am offering:


and they're offering:


is an up trade for me, even or a down trade?

also what does that dog go for? I really need help on that please!

[little dragon's Mum]

if I am offering:


and they're offering:


is an up trade for me, even or a down trade?

also what does that dog go for? I really need help on that please!

Your dog, the Cream Santa Hat Advent is on the Advent Rares List and is one tier above their Snowflake Lion. The difference between the two tiers if you are going by the list is an 09 rare.

[Kristalli]

Is this a fair trade?
Please explain you'r answer a bit ^_^

[account inactive]

Is this fair considering demand? Is it overpay?

[FenFen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WMTLe3IySA

this is a bid for there grown white scarf dog and I offered a Rudolph rat what would you rate that out of 10 she rated it a 6/10
is it fair?