The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[RedAtMidnight]

Is This Trade Fair?

I know the Cake Dog itself is technically overpay, but with demand and items.. I'm just not sure ._. Help?

Actually you don't need the items unless they really want it the cake dogs do have some bad demands from time to time but the store pet isn't needed just the 2010 rare and uncommons although it is overpay rarity wise but indeed the demand is kinda low so that's why the uncommons and 10 rare stay

Thank you! Second opinion please? And yes, they do like items (as far as I can tell).

[Castiel Winchester]

Im not sure what I should do here? How is the demand for the Dragon PPS
One more opinion

Actually the demand for the dragon PPS os Very high the fact their really hard to find in some cases but I've seen cerbs go for toxics because of their demand

Please be careful with how you word things.
Red Cerberus's do not usually go that high. Orange's had been for a while, however the actual demand has settled now that they've been moved up. It's been a while, and in the last month or two I have only seen one case of such high over-pay.
Both the Cerberus and the PPS have nice demand- about equal. You would need to make it fair tier wise for this to actually be fair to the dragon.

[DinoGoesRawr]

Is a 2013 staff pet and a rare calf from this advent fair for 2010 uncommon and very common 2013 dog?

Unfair to side with 2010 pet. 2014 rares are usually valued at an '11 uncommon.

Ok thanks what can I add to their side then?

[RedAtMidnight]

Is This Trade Fair?

I know the Cake Dog itself is technically overpay, but with demand and items.. I'm just not sure ._. Help?

Actually you don't need the items unless they really want it the cake dogs do have some bad demands from time to time but the store pet isn't needed just the 2010 rare and uncommons although it is overpay rarity wise but indeed the demand is kinda low so that's why the uncommons and 10 rare stay

Thank you! Second opinion please? And yes, they do like items (as far as I can tell).

[Kaidaft]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43049154&userid=664713&signature=VqFy2syAxyAWv3mGbwI9EA
This fair? Thanks!

And this one?:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43049249&userid=664713&signature=_pg-HsHIDWLQIgpIscztFA

[Alerian]

Im not sure what I should do here? How is the demand for the Dragon PPS
One more opinion

Actually the demand for the dragon PPS os Very high the fact their really hard to find in some cases but I've seen cerbs go for toxics because of their demand

Please be careful with how you word things.
Red Cerberus's do not usually go that high. Orange's had been for a while, however the actual demand has settled now that they've been moved up. It's been a while, and in the last month or two I have only seen one case of such high over-pay.
Both the Cerberus and the PPS have nice demand- about equal. You would need to make it fair tier wise for this to actually be fair to the dragon.

So demand wise this is fair?

[TeaCat]

Hi! I need some help. Is this offer fair?

[DinoGoesRawr]

Hi! I need some help. Is this offer fair?

Link doesn't work

[Deathstar1]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... rid=202502
Is this fair for a UR purple horse or a Gearback Tribal?
Please help, I want to know I'm not conning someone before he starts adding the pets

This looks unfair to the list pets. I didn't see any list pets in the group?

Re-posting, but how much do I need to add to make it fair to them? Thanks if anyone can help ^-^

Please can we have some help? Thanks. c:

[TeaCat]

Hi! I need some help. Is this offer fair?

Link doesn't work

Gah Dx
My laptop really does hate me ovo Should I take a screenshot of the trade or something x.x?