The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[24lovefancy]

Was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42776441&userid=586010&signature=T2fmd4ksSarLuk6Cm0baaA

[~GirlsDeMo~]

Was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42776441&userid=586010&signature=T2fmd4ksSarLuk6Cm0baaA

It was unfair to the Warrior Cat..

[starbit]

Is this fair? I know rats have pretty low demand but I'm not sure. I already have one of the dog and I'm not really looking for another.

[x]

[tenlittlesoldierboys]

Hello! c:
Could someone please tell me if this trade is fair? Or should be C$ added?
Thanks! :3

[Mental Disaster]

cancelled trade never mind.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Here's another one sorry
Light leopard +? =bmd

a scarf pps not considering demand

[debris]

Pretty sure it's unfair, but can someone help me and make sure? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CmDBNbvvWg

[~GirlsDeMo~]

Pretty sure it's unfair, but can someone help me and make sure? :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CmDBNbvvWg

the Store dog is worth a 2010 rare.. So they should at least add maybe a 2011 rare?? Or remove all the pets on their side and add a 2010 rare on their side

[Amplify]

Is this trade fair to me?

What about this one?

If I can could I also get these two checked out?
X
X

Wrong links. Use the [Share Trade] Tab at where it says You partner is waiting for your reply blah blah thing lol

But I did. I just re went through them, clicking on the share link point and copying the link given to me in the white box in the center of the message you just spoke of.

In any case, here are the contents of the trades.

the first trade involves a person offering me a...
2010-6-30 rare, a 2010-08-01 uncommon, 2011-09-01 uncommon, a 2012-11-1 rare, and then a 2014-12-20 unknown rarity

for a...
shadow creature item.

--------------

the second trade involves a person offering me a...
2011-12-18 Rerelease Green Grinner

for a...
Desert Swirl PPS; A Pink, Purple, white string tess horse; late 2009/2010/2011 rares [one from each year]; an early 2011 rare, some mixed recent items [8] and then 12 C$.

--------------

the third trade involves a person offering me a...
3 late 2014 uncommons, 4 late unknown rarities, a late very common, and then a late common.

for a...
Grass Item []

--------------

the fourth trade involves a person offering me a...
T h e s e . . .
5 mid 2010 Uncommons, a late 2010 common, 4 late 2011 uncommons, an early 2012 uncommon, a late 2012 uncommon, a late 2012 common and a mid 2014 uncommon.

for a...
Very rare corgi store pet [brown one.]

[Hiia :mrgreen:]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2-ey8peMaA
is this fair?!!?!?! its a cobweb bun!