The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[doggo]

What is worth three of those seven tier mid advents?

Both pets are worth six 7th tier advents. A scarf pps would be fair for their advents.

Hi is this fair? C:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42962803&userid=559358&signature=Rr_lHdnN9kRa4mMc_crP2Q

Can i have a second opinion on this please?

Due to three months rule the pps dog alone would be fair.

Thanks! Can i have a third opinion? :3

[korok]

I have two trades:

1. is this fair both rarity and demand wise? Does the butterfly wolf have good demand? Are butterfly wolves easy to trade off?
2. Do their pets have good demand?

[lumos .]

Hi is this fair? C:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42962803&userid=559358&signature=Rr_lHdnN9kRa4mMc_crP2Q

Can i have a second opinion on this please?

Due to three months rule the pps dog alone would be fair.[/quote]
Thanks! Can i have a third opinion? :3[/quote]

They're making you overpay quite a bit. The pps is fair enough, as it follows the 3-6 month rule. C:

[jubilee.]

Joker+Gwj+6Grinners+Purple Tox+2Sorbets+Blue Balloon+Target Dog+Angel Advent+?=Moonswirl?
Thanks for help in advance!


I'd say you have to add a non and a UR butterbun. My method is quite complex so if you want it you can PM me. However, the demand of the Joker is very odd - it goes for unusually huge amounts. I've set it as a non in this calculation, but you can see what it goes for if you search the auctions.



Can someone help me with this one? :3

Thanks for every opinion! C:


It's very unfair to them. There's no list pets at all on your side, and their pet is a high september.



I have two trades:

1. is this fair both rarity and demand wise? Does the butterfly wolf have good demand? Are butterfly wolves easy to trade off?
2. Do their pets have good demand?


1: Unfair to them by an advent. Remember that only in the case of the BA and the Joker does the rares list not take demand entirely into account (if they went by demand, the joker would be above the gap, and the BA on the main list).
2: I answered the other person in this trade earlier, actually ! And if you change the '09 rare to one from early '09, it will be fair.



Thanks! Can i have a third opinion? :3


I agree, the PPS dog alone would be fair.



considering demand, would my nonjewel=someone's pickle?
Looking at the list I'd say it is, but I wasn't sure if the pickle was hard to trade off since I'm really not looking to keep it from there,


Unfair to nonjewel. The pickle has bad demand.


alright!
Thanks


No no no, I completely disagree! The cucumber is worth more than double a non-jewel, so even though it's demand isn't brilliant it's still unfair to it !!

[doggo]

Hi is this fair? C:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42962803&userid=559358&signature=Rr_lHdnN9kRa4mMc_crP2Q

Can i have a second opinion on this please?

Due to three months rule the pps dog alone would be fair.

Thanks! Can i have a third opinion? :3[/quote]

They're making you overpay quite a bit. The pps is fair enough, as it follows the 3-6 month rule. C:[/quote]
Thanks! What can be added on their side to make it fair?

[odin]

Can I please have another opinion on this? I've had one say it was unfair to the lion (they said they'd seen the lion go for a lot at auction) & one said it was unfair to the dog.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dOWmgXsKXQ

[Castiel Winchester]

A Red Toxic would be worth about 50 mid advents, correct?

[boktimater]

is this fair? thanks in advance C:

[~GirlsDeMo~]

considering demand, would my nonjewel=someone's pickle?
Looking at the list I'd say it is, but I wasn't sure if the pickle was hard to trade off since I'm really not looking to keep it from there,

Unfair to nonjewel. The pickle has bad demand.

alright!
Thanks

I disagree

A UR Pickle even with its horrible demand.. is worth double the Nonjewels value (I think) but it would still be unfair to the pickle.. Remember.. The Rares List takes into account DEMAND and RARITY.. But it depends on who you trade with

[doggo]

Hi heres a trade i have just got. any advice is helpful! Thanks so much
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43006447&userid=559358&signature=ihOiU8-yiCkqHbvO0zKTDQ