The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Darkreh]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42905857&userid=672965&signature=mZycz69nZ9WcUDKOt2aCIQ
Would this be fair? Thanks!

Looks fair to me

Thanks! Second opinion please?

pretty unfair to you, I'd say. they're offering one 2009 rare and asking for two of yours plus I believe a halloween rare cat (from 2010 or 2011? ) and the commons they added don't add up to it ^^;

[demolition lovers]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42905857&userid=672965&signature=mZycz69nZ9WcUDKOt2aCIQ
Would this be fair? Thanks!

Looks fair to me

Thanks! Second opinion please?

It looks unfair to you, but get another opinion as you have two different ones

[miyadera]

I was gonna say it looked unfair, But I'm not an expert. at this stuff.. At all..

[TIGRESS♥]

Hi there! How does this look, demand wise? Thank you!

[CSF]

Hi there! How does this look, demand wise? Thank you!

I believe that's unfair to them. Demand wise the Malk element cat can do quite well. Get another opinion though.

[miyadera]

Is

fair for
and
All of these are uncommon, Cat is 2010, Dog and deer are 2014

[Zetirian]

Hi there! How does this look, demand wise? Thank you!

I believe that's unfair to them. Demand wise the Malk element cat can do quite well. Get another opinion though.

Unfair to the top. All things considered, rarity wise; the two '09 dogs are a straight swap, though the White Feb on the bottom has slight demand, so it could go for more and from demand alone, it could be classed as a fair trade, though this is up to you and your partner. ^^

Is

fair for
and
All of these are uncommon, Cat is 2010, Dog and deer are 2014

Unfair to the cat.
The cat would probably be, if I am able to math correctly; worth 4 uncommon '14 pets.

[TIGRESS♥]

Is

fair for
and
All of these are uncommon, Cat is 2010, Dog and deer are 2014

I'd say not fair to the sitting cat, there's a really big age gap between the pets plus the sitting cat line art is pretty popular.

And thanks CSF and Levi Ackerman for the help!

[miyadera]

Is this fair?
Rare and Uncommon
for
Rare and Rare
Thanks

[Lunamione7]

Is this trade fair: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FfznV3rUqA

Thank you to anyone who can advise.