The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[rentoh]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7glGv0MSzQ

Is this fair?

[kebabonline]

How fair is this? Thanks http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42902238&userid=79520&signature=tId2pcJoAHVQEd011ov3sw

Unfair to the top. The scarf is from Dec. 2010, there's nothing fancy about it; it isn't worth an '09 rare.

According to the "CS Items Guide" that scarf is worth an early 09 rare '-'

Interesting, thank you for letting me know, It'll still be unfair to the top with the additional '09 rare attached, but the dog and the uncommons would be a good trade for it.

[kebabonline]

I was wondering if this is fair? I'm just checking for a friend. Thanks for any help in advance!

Unfair to the dragons.

I disagree, this would be unfair to the top; the dragons are worth early-mid '10 rares, and there's already one on the top side, plus all those uncommons. That more than bridges the gap in price.

[kebabonline]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42896389&userid=664079&signature=kC6GjSBj9EqUUO7Q9otMmA
Is that fair? ^_^

Unfair to the items, imo. The halo is worth a low September, and the two Pocky's are both mid-advents; the scarfs are low advents, and I think those + all the extra items there would be overpayment.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42902098&userid=672842&signature=ujOk_vrdo-8h7glGv0MSzQ

Is this fair?

No, you'd need more uncommons on the top side. The pony has very low demand and is 9 months younger.

[Catfight]

I was wondering if this is fair? I'm just checking for a friend. Thanks for any help in advance!

Unfair to the dragons.

I disagree, this would be unfair to the top; the dragons are worth early-mid '10 rares, and there's already one on the top side, plus all those uncommons. That more than bridges the gap in price.

It's unfair to the store dragons. The top does not add up to 4 '10 rares.

[LibertyyAJJ]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42896389&userid=664079&signature=kC6GjSBj9EqUUO7Q9otMmA
Is that fair? ^_^

its unfair to the dragon.

[Seiya001]

Hope someone can help me with These trades
1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6llPlciBQg
2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eSclhIkAzw
3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Z1UVu56EHQ

#1. Unfair to top, that dutch bun is on the advent list.

#2. Roughly fair, if not a bit overpaying with the items

#3. Unfair to bottom imo, the dog plushie has high demand. But it isn't unfair by much.

Thank you. Maybe second opinion on 2nd and 3rd trade and what could be deleted in the first trade to make it fair ?
( without the list bunny ?)

[vulpes vulpes]

Is This Fair? Thank you to anyone who answers

[beautea]

Hello!
I'm unsure if this is fair?
My pet is a Moonswirl, and their coon pup is a Non-Coon, so would this be fair to me?
Please only have experienced answers, thanks for any responses!

They're off by a low-level main list pet imo; they have about 23 mid-advents (counting the '09 rares and store pets and items) plus the skeleton PPS and the non-coon. Needs something at the Orange Cerb level or lower, a second opinion wouldn't be a bad idea.

Okay, thank you! Second opinions please? c:

[Party Poison.]

Is This Fair? Thank you to anyone who answers

It looks fair to me, maybe a bit overpay on the rat's side but the demand for the aussie might make its value higher? I would get a second opinion