The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[love miccado]

Would this be Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=42360390&userid=342711&signature=mEAyou52XJ-2yx1ky9HRLg

Thanks for help!

[Vexious]

Fair?

[Flamestar0809]

fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OSUwoWnJ5g

[VRA]

Fair?

yes, i think so

[lucifer morningstar]

Hi everyone <3 I would like to know which would be better:

| This |

Or | This | and
| Also this |

Guys, they're asking about which is better. Consider it as if they're asking which bid is better for their pet.
I believe the first one is better, but I'm not great with quantity, so I'd get a second opinion to be sure.

[Goostarion]

The UR Apple + _____= UR cucumber or UR Phoenix

Ur Apple + Nonballoon + 2 Nondogs = Ur Cucumber / Ur Banana Line. (I believe, ask for a second opinion if you need to)

[newt.]

Hi everyone <3 I would like to know which would be better:

| This |

Or | This | and
| Also this |

Guys, they're asking about which is better. Consider it as if they're asking which bid is better for their pet.
I believe the first one is better, but I'm not great with quantity, so I'd get a second opinion to be sure.

I'd be easier to answer if we're knew what pet the bids are for...

[Nachtbringer]

Hey guys, I need some help. A member wants a large number of items from me and I am not sure what to ask them for because I am not good at item(or pet) trades.

The trade can be viewed HERE.

It has on my end:
9 2010 items
58 2011 items
12 2012 items
11 2013 items

On hers is a september list rat.

How can I make it fair for her, OR if I remove the rat, what should I ask for the items.

[Vexious]

Fair?

Second Opinoin please?

[lucifer morningstar]

fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OSUwoWnJ5g

Rarity wise unfair to them. The pps cub will probably only be an uncommon at best. Right now, the demand is pretty high, but it will probably die off after the event ends.