The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[A Vengeful God]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41695692&userid=684745&signature=qnbymwKH_TlG9KbftPvJZQ

is it fair

They are overpaying, rarity wise, since your cat is a re-release from '09

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Fair I would like multiple opinions please and thank you!

unfair to you
Your store pet is worth a mid 09 rare and those uncommons aren't worth quite that ^^

Thank you! Any more opinions?

Add an uncommon or 2

more than that is needed
I would say a later 2010 rare would be needed

[River Blossom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41695692&userid=684745&signature=qnbymwKH_TlG9KbftPvJZQ

is it fair

They are overpaying, rarity wise, since your cat is a re-release from '09

cN I HAVE A second opinion

[musicgurl333]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41695692&userid=684745&signature=qnbymwKH_TlG9KbftPvJZQ

is it fair

They are overpaying, rarity wise, since your cat is a re-release from '09

cN I HAVE A second opinion

I'm not sure I agree that they're overpaying. The malk cat is from Februray 2009 and the pony is from 5 months later. The pony alone wouldn't be fair, so they need the other pets to make up for the gap. I'm not sure if they would be enough or not. I'd get another opinion on that. It's also worth keeping in mind that malk cats have much higher demand than ponies.

[River Blossom]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9KbftPvJZQ

any ideas what they should add

[moosetachio]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41695692&userid=684745&signature=qnbymwKH_TlG9KbftPvJZQ

is it fair

They are overpaying, rarity wise, since your cat is a re-release from '09

cN I HAVE A second opinion

I'm not sure I agree that they're overpaying. The malk cat is from Februray 2009 and the pony is from 5 months later. The pony alone wouldn't be fair, so they need the other pets to make up for the gap. I'm not sure if they would be enough or not. I'd get another opinion on that. It's also worth keeping in mind that malk cats have much higher demand than ponies.

Unfair to the malk cat rarity and demand wise. The cat is a feb '09 re-release. Demand wise, ponies have bad demand while malk cats have above decent to good demand.

[TheLittleBlackCat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9KbftPvJZQ

is it fair

They are overpaying, rarity wise, since your cat is a re-release from '09

can I HAVE A second opinion

It's Fair. It doesn't matter weather something is a re-rerelease or not they end up with the same rarity!

[✌ pineapples ✌]

Does

Drink Me dog :for: Yellow Punk Dog = unfair for Drink Me?

Help please and thank you!

[ShadyCat]

Does

Drink Me dog :for: Yellow Punk Dog = unfair for Drink Me?

Help please and thank you!

it's unfair to the drink me. The drink me is a September list pet with good demand while the yellow punk is just an advent list pet and it's demand isn't as high.

[a sky full of stars]

Advice on this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=41701498