The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[lucky333123]

Would a Red Cerberus + Green Liontail be fair for a Scarf PPS, or no?
What would need to be added to the Scarf PPS's side to make it fair rarity wise?


I don't trade by demand as the rares list already takes that into account, so rarity only please.


Any help appreciated. c:

Unfair to you rarity wise. Technically a mini husky tier and 1 '09 rare will make up the difference between the Scarf PPS and Red Cerberus.

I know it's unfair to me, but thank you! c:

I'm trying to kill two or three birds with one stone.


For example;
A Red Cerb + Green Liontail + ? = Scarf PPS

I'm wondering what that missing pet(s) is on what tier since I know it's unfair to the Scarf PPS. c:

[/quote]

It is actually unfair to you. I'm not taking demand into account. The green liontail is too much. They would need to add to their side - about 2 '09 rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41099513&userid=655245&signature=vzbMHFC6QJn_XAS-BbSKTg is it fair?

Unfair to you - that item isn't worth 1 C$ at the moment.

[Bat-Country]

Before I send this, is it fair?

[lucky333123]

Before I send this, is it fair?

Unfair to them, both rarity wise and demand wise

[Bat-Country]

Before I send this, is it fair?

Unfair to them, both rarity wise and demand wise

What would make it fair?

[lucky333123]

Before I send this, is it fair?

Unfair to them, both rarity wise and demand wise

What would make it fair?

Do you want us to include demand or just strictly rarity wise only?

[~Rick Sanchez~]

Snowflake Lion+ ????= Red Blood Tuft

[Hyrule]

It is actually unfair to you. I'm not taking demand into account. The green liontail is too much. They would need to add to their side - about 2 '09 rares.

Oh, are you talking about the Cerbs side?


You see, I've got a Scarf PPS and want to kill two birds with one stone.
I would be the Scarf PPS's side.
So this is all hypothetically speaking.



So it's unfair with the Green Liontail involved?
What would I have to add to my side with the Green Liontail involved?




I got an answer on here before saying it was unfair to the Red Cerb and Green Liontail due to demand, but rarity wise unfair to the Scarf PPS?



Now I'm just confused or don't understand clearly.

[Bat-Country]

Unfair to them, both rarity wise and demand wise

What would make it fair?

Do you want us to include demand or just strictly rarity wise only?

Both, I guess?

[nelly,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41158385&userid=611894&signature=xHsQmq3qAaS-OBjVjHdXbg
And
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41158369&userid=611894&signature=HTjWq33tJR8PdZ0iiLax3g
Thanks in advance =)

1. Unfair rarity wise but demand wise Nick dogs don't have great demand.
2. Unfair to the '13 rat

So demand wise.. what do they need to add?

[lucky333123]

Snowflake Lion+ ????= Red Blood Tuft

1 '09 rare

It is actually unfair to you. I'm not taking demand into account. The green liontail is too much. They would need to add to their side - about 2 '09 rares.

Oh, are you talking about the Cerbs side?


You see, I've got a Scarf PPS and want to kill two birds with one stone.
I would be the Scarf PPS's side.
So this is all hypothetically speaking.



So it's unfair with the Green Liontail involved?
What would I have to add to my side with the Green Liontail involved?




I got an answer on here before saying it was unfair to the Red Cerb and Green Liontail due to demand, but rarity wise unfair to the Scarf PPS?



Now I'm just confused or don't understand clearly.

Yes I was talking about the Cerberus side.

Either way it is unfair to you both rarity and demand wise.

The scarf PPS is almost worth 3 midadvents. The Red Cerberus is almost worth 2 midadvents. The Green Liontail is a high advent thus you are overpaying slightly by about 2 '09 rares.

Demand wise it is also unfair to you since both the cerberus and the green liontail have great demand while the scarf pps doesn't have much demand.

Hopefully that will make you a bit less confused.

]

Unfair to them, both rarity wise and demand wise

What would make it fair?

Do you want us to include demand or just strictly rarity wise only?

Both, I guess?[/quote]

The Christmas Tree Dog is worth about 5 early '09 rares approx.

The Marrionette Dog's demand can easily go for a high midadvent = around 7 '09 rares.

Their dogs are worth at least an '09 rare and an '10 rare each = 3 '09 rares and 3 '10 rares

Their side in total is about 10 '09 rares and 3 '10 rares demand wise.

Without demand it is 5 '09 rares and 3 '10 rares.

Most users will take demand into account. The Christmas Tree Dog doesn't have very good demand.