The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[oliver,]

is this fair, demand and rarity wise?thanks for the help guys! more opinions?

edit: I edited my trade! now is it fair?!?!?

[Castiel Winchester]

Could anybody help me with this?
If you wouldn't mind, could you explain who it is unfair to, your math behind it, and how to fix it?

[Castiel Winchester]

-snip-

not sure.. other suggestions?

I would say this looks unfair to you. Your items are primarily from the C$ shop, and worth at least 4-5 C$ each. That meas 4 or 5 of your items per 2010 rare, and then maybe 8 for the 2009.. Not exact, counted out values, but rough estimates.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39329163&userid=19680&signature=4XywbbFqXutxq25ziUbrYA

Is this fair? Keep in consideration that I don't need the foxes at all for my wishlist so they are alittle lower, if not just fodder for better pets...

I would say unfair to you by another mid 2009 rare. They have the equivalent of roughly two late 2009s.

is this fair, demand and rarity wise?thanks for the help guys! more opions?

Unfair to the Lolita by at least another 2009 rare. Including demand, they could probably get a 7th or 8th tier easily.

[Chronostasis]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Kv9Sb5_vEw

[Daniel.Caylen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ox8Z0qQ92w is this fair ?

[KyoshiYan]

meow
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1ZUNnHb4Qg

What can I remove for it to be fair on my side since I am overpaying?

I think you should remove the store dog. The 2010 dog itself is very high in demand. Maybe add some more uncommon to your side after removing the two store pets.

Need more opinions!

[[Shadow]]

I am pretty sure this is fair but the other person didn't think so... Opinions?

[Topiratti]

In regards to my Shima Long Tail auction, i have TWO bids that I really like.

ONE.

and

TWO.

which one would be the best to accept

[musicgurl333]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39329505&userid=649818&signature=ts1CHrw3uOwXKv9Sb5_vEw

Very unfair to them. Plus, the White February on their side has a lot of demand.

[Cavy's Girl]

What out of these pets can I edit this trade to to make it fair for both of us?

=Rare, =Rare, =Very Rare, =Very Rare, =Very Rare
They are currently offering these 2 pets:
=Very Rare, =Rare

,

<-Both are true date 2009.

I would like it to be fair to both of us if possible, but I would also prefer older pets.