The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[veckster]

Omg! Help? Fair to me? *Click!* If its not fair to me, what can be added? What is the highest a UR apple goes for?

unfair to you - the apple has pretty bad demand and usually goes for half of what it's worth, maybe even less than that ^^ you could get more with the apple, but you'd have to be very patient.

Oh thanks ^_^ Second opinion please? :3

[lizziecat1279]

Is this fair to me or are those items absurd overpay with the pets on their side? Note, I'm looking for a little overpay ^^;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2RQGxEHQA

[Castiel Winchester]

Any help for this please?
Anyone?

I'd say unfair to you.

Second opinion?

Agreed - that's definitely unfair to you. There are a few ways you could edit it but you could either leave just the VR rainbow dog, blood dog, and two of the bottom-tier advents on your side OR you could take off the blood dog and stone dog.

Could I get somebody to explain why it's worth so little? The list says it's worth at leastt wo mid advents, and I have on ever heard of mid advents being the 7th tier pets, and that's with any rares list trader. There's no way two first tiers and a 5th would make for that..[/quote]

[fang0fang]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39274256&userid=617870&signature=Le4o3pxxbeDxA9aC9th1_Q

Fair??

Yeah, that looks about fair. Though staff pets are high in demand, many 2010-2013 may be able to cover it. I think it looks quite fair, though get a second opinion.

Thanks. I'll put that in mind. That was what I was thinking too. However, may I please have some more advice, just to make sure.

[niceplant]

Fair?:3

looks fair, maybe slightly unfair to them

[fang0fang]

Is this fair to me or are those items absurd overpay with the pets on their side? Note, I'm looking for a little overpay ^^;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a2RQGxEHQA

Its already a very big overpay on their side.

[undefined realities]

Could I get somebody to explain why it's worth so little? The list says it's worth at leastt wo mid advents, and I have on ever heard of mid advents being the 7th tier pets, and that's with any rares list trader. There's no way two first tiers and a 5th would make for that..[/quote][/quote]


This is just a guys, BUT, I think it's because demand on the cat has died down. All the pets on your side have great demand, and I believe some are on the rares list. The 8-legged horse thing alone is extremely unfair to you. I'd recommend a second opinion as well c:

[Raven_Stephanie]

Need an answer ASAP: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tFUP8N0xjw
Thank you for any answers!!! Is it fair, or is one or another overpaying?

[undefined realities]

Need an answer ASAP: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tFUP8N0xjw
Thank you for any answers!!! Is it fair, or is one or another overpaying?

Looks unfair to you.

[Jessi.]

Any help for this please?

It's unfair to the top. Ignoring everything except the list pets on your side,
you have four first tiers and a fifth tier. That only adds up to a ninth tier advent, which is not enough for the cat.
Demand really is up to the person's opinion. However, list wise, it's unfair.