The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Applenz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cTQMbWBqjQ
Is this fair? Thanks.

[hellhunt]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39169122&userid=443036&signature=2oWEdz7ZrS39cgZitDfDnQ

Is this fair? Thanks.

Unfair to you. The 2010 rare is enough and maybe the 2010 uncommon as well but the other two uncommons and the item are not needed

Thanks, and second opinions before I edit the offer?

I do agree on that. Rare (+ maybe 1 uncommon) is enough

[hellhunt]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39147830&userid=98981&signature=d_FrNBOsoGvGcTQMbWBqjQ
Is this fair? Thanks.

I would go unfair to you
Rex pps is worth 10 advent dogs (mid advent's I imagine)
On your side I see 4 mid advents (1 is cat though, but they have about same demand that dogs), grinner (that is worth 2 mid advents) + 4 low advents and 5 09 rares and a bunch of '10 rares and store dog + C$

[Applenz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39147830&userid=98981&signature=d_FrNBOsoGvGcTQMbWBqjQ
Is this fair? Thanks.

I would go unfair to you
Rex pps is worth 10 advent dogs (mid advent's I imagine)
On your side I see 4 mid advents (1 is cat though, but they have about same demand that dogs), grinner (that is worth 2 mid advents) + 4 low advents and 5 09 rares and a bunch of '10 rares and store dog + C$

Thank you

[LaceWhiskey]

✮ I believe this may be unfair to me, so I'd like a second opinion.

Here is the trade. Thank you.

✮ Also, what could be added to their side for the card dog?
I tend to get a lot of offers for it, so pets range a lot, which can be confusing.

Here is the trade. Thank you again.

[Meraa]

I have troubles with trades I got so they start rotting and I feel sorry. Can you please help me so that I can finally respond?

What would be needed to make those fair?
one
two

Would this without the pet and pearl headpiece be fair?
three

This guy said he would overpay huge for those:
four
I don't care so much for the bunny, but I guess he really wants them and I'd be ok to part with all except the floating rock. Would the trade be approximately fair without it? (Sorry, I don't know much about item trades!)

And then there is this trade:
five
I want to keep a pair of the 2013 uncommons and one of each butterfly wolves. And I'm too unsure to trade the chesire. What would the rest of the pets be worth (in one or max two pets) approximately?

Sorry for the many trades and thank you for any advice on one of them!

[Jackdaw Lord]

✮ I believe this may be unfair to me, so I'd like a second opinion.

Here is the trade. Thank you.

✮ Also, what could be added to their side for the card dog?
I tend to get a lot of offers for it, so pets range a lot, which can be confusing.

Here is the trade. Thank you again.

First trade is indeed unfair to you, the flop blood dog is on the advent list and none of their pets really add up to it.

I'm not sure on the second one, the card dog isn't on the list, but pretty sure it's unfair to you as well. I'm going to guess they should probably add at least a 09 rare to it, but well, I'm not the best at this sorta' questions.

[Leaf.]

Is this fair??

[KatRose]

Is this fair?

[caesou]

Is this fair??

Wrong link.

image.jpg (358.6 KiB) Viewed 50 times

Click on "Share Trade", and it should leave you the URL to send the trade over to anyone you like without trouble.