The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[niceplant]

how is this, demand and rarity wise?

thanks

any help is appreciated, just need opinions

[Quillington]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=38903956&userid=456385&signature=YAB-Q82Y5qOblfaDFonejA

I heard that this advent is worth 6-7 2009 rares . . . so this is fair or overpay right? Correct me if I'm wrong, I usually don't trade off the list.

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=38903956&userid=456385&signature=YAB-Q82Y5qOblfaDFonejA

I heard that this advent is worth 6-7 2009 rares . . . so this is fair or overpay right? Correct me if I'm wrong, I usually don't trade off the list.

Unfair to them.

[Chaosin]

how is this, demand and rarity wise?

thanks

any help is appreciated, just need opinions

I want to say it's unfair to the top, but I know the BMD has some pretty good demand.
Rares List wise, minus the demand I think it's unfair. With demand... I don't know. I have no idea honestly what the BMD goes for now.
That's just my two cents, that it's unfair to the top.
But, I'd have someone else give their opinion, too. ^^;;

[niceplant]

how is this, demand and rarity wise?

thanks

any help is appreciated, just need opinions

I want to say it's unfair to the top, but I know the BMD has some pretty good demand.
Rares List wise, minus the demand I think it's unfair. With demand... I don't know. I have no idea honestly what the BMD goes for now.
That's just my two cents, that it's unfair to the top.
But, I'd have someone else give their opinion, too. ^^;;

thank you, what should i add?

[sienna77]

hi there, I am auctioning of some rare rats for quantity uncommons to go into my newbie giveaway, I want to make sure I have fair offers for them though, so any help would be appreciated, thanks.

Here are the offers I want to know about...

offer 1
offer 2
offer 3
offer 4

thanks in advance for any help! XD

[Username Unknown]

Which bid is better in terms of demand and rarity? Thanks.

bid 1 for my GSD

Bid 2
added onto bid 2

The first one.

Thanks, and second opinion please?

[Ashki]

Which bid is better in terms of demand and rarity? Thanks.

bid 1 for my GSD

Bid 2
added onto bid 2

The first one.

Thanks, and second opinion please?

Agreed - the first bid is the best. ^^

[c a l a m i t y]

hi there, I am auctioning of some rare rats for quantity uncommons to go into my newbie giveaway, I want to make sure I have fair offers for them though, so any help would be appreciated, thanks.

Here are the offers I want to know about...

offer 1
offer 2
offer 3
offer 4

thanks in advance for any help! XD

The first is fair maybe slightly unfair to them since their all 2013 in the trade.The rest seem unfair to you since they're 2010 rats.

[finest desperation]

Is this fair? I'm not sure what the VR dog is worth D:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yq9SuBSmtw