The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[alucards345]

My auction has ended and I must choose between these two trades, which should I choose?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gI5rU_VK2A
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DrX-ScqXSQ

Thanks~!

In my opinion the first one rareity wise is more overpay I think

[sketchi]

^I would agree, but then I really love nick dogs. :B

Bid 1
Bid 2

can I get an opinion on which bid is better? thanks!

[Lady Sif]

^I would agree, but then I really love nick dogs. :B

Bid 1
Bid 2

can I get an opinion on which bid is better? thanks!

What are they bidding for?

My auction has ended and I must choose between these two trades, which should I choose?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gI5rU_VK2A
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DrX-ScqXSQ

Thanks~!

In my opinion the first one rareity wise is more overpay I think

I disagree. The second one looks better to me.

[Celeste Fay]

^I would agree, but then I really love nick dogs. :B

Bid 1
Bid 2

can I get an opinion on which bid is better? thanks!

What are they bidding for?

I think sketchi just wants to know the values

The first one is worth more in that case

[sketchi]

^thank you! and wow, I would not have guessed that. 0.0

^I would agree, but then I really love nick dogs. :B

Bid 1
Bid 2

can I get an opinion on which bid is better? thanks!

What are they bidding for?

art stuff, haha. no fairness to balance on my side!

[Jordan.goodman]

This fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FKDBqPbDAg

[Lady Sif]

^thank you! and wow, I would not have guessed that. 0.0

^I would agree, but then I really love nick dogs. :B

Bid 1
Bid 2

can I get an opinion on which bid is better? thanks!

What are they bidding for?

art stuff, haha. no fairness to balance on my side!

Ah, okay.

I agree with Chasm, the first one is worth more.

This fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FKDBqPbDAg

Very unfair to you.

[Jordan.goodman]

What does it need to be fair

[*~Sharni~*]

Would this list here~

Yellow Sorbet (Main List)
Line Tribal (Main List)
Blue Balloon (Main List)
Angel Advent (September List)
BMD (September List)
Drink Me (September List)
Brown Sleipnir (Advent List)
Vixen (Advent List)
Evil PPS (Advent List)
Marionette Dog (Advent List)
White Feb (Non List)
Shima Longtail (Non List)

Be fair to ask for in return for a Non-Tag?

thank you for any help guys <3

[FreddyCenobite]

What should be added to this?

(I'm the list dog side)

Given that a 2012 rare is supposed to be worth a 2009 rare (Late) than I would say about fair to a bit unfair to them.

Thank you!