The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Celeste Fay]

Unfair to the bottom ^^

[inactive/gone]

Red-X PPS = Dark Shima B-Wolf?

[Celeste Fay]

Red-X PPS = Dark Shima B-Wolf?

⌘ unfair to the b-wolf ^^ ⌘

[cloudStriker]

Is this fair? C: thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 11iCL2x6HQ

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

is this a fair offer?

Very unfair to the 09 cat.

Unless I'm missing something, I don't understand how it's unfair to the cat. The store pet is quite old, I assume it would be worth an '09 rare and the other pets + C$ cover up the gap and I think it's unfair to the Store pet side.

Thank you, can i get another opinion or two since i have two different ones right now, thanks.

unfair to you
the cat is worth a mid-late 09 very rare. or two late 09 rares
the horse is worth a mid-early 09 rare at least and the lion is a late 09 rare

[Celeste Fay]

Is this fair? C: thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 11iCL2x6HQ

⌘ i'd say unfair to the aussie ⌘

[inactive/gone]

Red-X PPS = Dark Shima B-Wolf?

⌘ unfair to the b-wolf ^^ ⌘

Okay thank you! I didn't know if it would be fair or unfair because I had no clue if the Red-X had good demand or not.

[Rain Firis]

My auction has ended and I must choose between these two trades, which should I choose?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gI5rU_VK2A
or
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DrX-ScqXSQ

Thanks~!

[*~Sharni~*]

Would this list here~

Yellow Sorbet (Main List)
Line Tribal (Main List)
Blue Balloon (Main List)
Angel Advent (September List)
BMD (September List)
Drink Me (September List)
Brown Sleipnir (Advent List)
Vixen (Advent List)
Evil PPS (Advent List)
Marionette Dog (Advent List)
White Feb (Non List)
Shima Longtail (Non List)

Be fair to ask for in return for a Non-Tag?

thank you for any help guys <3

[NocturnalPanda]

Would 36 mixed '10 uncommons be fair for 4 Jan '09 rare dogs? If not, how many more/less '10 uncommons would be needed to make it fair? Thanks!