The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[anchor]

How fair is this trade? I was offered the money for my very rare pet, no idea if it's fair or not! I'm new here, so if anyone could also explain what it would be worth, if this is unfair. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=38885643

[Kex.]

How fair is this trade? I was offered the money for my very rare pet, no idea if it's fair or not! I'm new here, so if anyone could also explain what it would be worth, if this is unfair. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=38885643

The link is wrong, please click "Share Trade" so we can see c:

is this a fair offer?

Very unfair to the 09 cat.

Unless I'm missing something, I don't understand how it's unfair to the cat. The store pet is quite old, I assume it would be worth an '09 rare and the other pets + C$ cover up the gap and I think it's unfair to the Store pet side.

[koalanews [QUIT]]

Fair? Thanks.

[Kex.]

Fair? Thanks.

I think it's fair. Even though their pet is from '09 and yours is from '10, the gap is only three months so I'd say that's fine.

[anchor]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Cwp6DR0Alg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... iFPRYZUNOQ

Sorry about the link. Do these work? Are these fair? If not, how can they be made fair?

[Kex.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=38885643&userid=664338&signature=Q1dWoW0_bcOyCwp6DR0Alg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... iFPRYZUNOQ

Sorry about the link. Do these work? Are these fair? If not, how can they be made fair?

The first one is very unfair to them. The store pet would only be worth 22-25C$ or so.
I'm not exactly sure about the second one, though. Personally, I would just trade one horse for the bunny, but that's just me so you might want to get a second opinion about that one.

[anchor]

So should I accept the first one? I'll do as you say, and try and get a second opinion on the second trade. Thanks!

[Kex.]

So should I accept the first one? I'll do as you say, and try and get a second opinion on the second trade. Thanks!

That depends on you? I don't really like trading unfairly so I'd edit to 25C$ or something to make it fair to them, but if you're fine with taking overpay it's your call.

[anchor]

So should I accept the first one? I'll do as you say, and try and get a second opinion on the second trade. Thanks!

That depends on you? I don't really like trading unfairly so I'd edit to 25C$ or something to make it fair to them, but if you're fine with taking overpay it's your call.

Taking more than it's worth doesn't seem very fair, but they offered it, so I really have no idea. I'll think about it for a while, thank you!

[toxikphantom]

is this a fair trade? :3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Mp81S8IjuA