The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[hellhunt]

Let me rephrase my original question:
joker bunny = red x pps + grinner + dark grey tag husky + light gray speckeled husky + chrismastree dog + snoflake lion + blue snoflake scarf dog
what needs to be added to make it fair?

[Chaosin]

Those two values - value in pets and in C$ don't always go hand in hand when it comes to list pets.
Though mid advent would be worth 60-65C$, it's still is not considered fair to advent when someone offers full collection of current store-pets for it.

Let me rephrase my original question:
joker bunny = red x pps + grinner + dark grey tag husky + light gray speckeled husky + chrismastree dog + snoflake lion + blue snoflake scarf dog
what needs to be added to make it fair?

So, currently you're around UR Purple Tess Horse-Speckled Rat area (If I did my calculations right).
A Joker Bun equals a Rainbow Mane + a Floppy Pink September according to the Rares List gap break down.
So, I'd say a low main list..?
I could be wrong and I'd get a second opinion.

[FOUND VERDICT]

Let me rephrase my original question:
joker bunny = red x pps + grinner + dark grey tag husky + light gray speckeled husky + chrismastree dog + snoflake lion + blue snoflake scarf dog
what needs to be added to make it fair?

at least an high September list, but please get a second opinion

[hellhunt]

thank you both
just did my rarity math on whole trade using rare list gap addition and got about low list/3 mid/low sept pets.
So the magnitude seems about right!
thank you <3

[Chaosin]

thank you both
just did my rarity math on whole trade using rare list gap addition and got about low list/3 mid/low sept pets.
So the magnitude seems about right!
thank you <3

You're welcome ^^

[JuneyAmy]

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

[Silverstar]

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

Unfair to UR Cookie.

[FOUND VERDICT]

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

including demand, all store pets would go for quite more than a cookie.
Seeing that I'm offered an Cookie for two Orange Cerbs alone, demand is really high for certain store pets.

[JuneyAmy]

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

Unfair to UR Cookie.

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

including demand, all store pets would go for quite more than a cookie.
Seeing that I'm offered an Cookie for two Orange Cerbs alone, demand is really high for certain store pets.

alright with 2 different opinions im quite confused. and a UR cookie for just 2 cerbs?! O.o wow!!

[Chaosin]

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

Unfair to UR Cookie.

Would all store pets ( literally all ) would be worth a UR cookie? mine is for auction,but i have no idea what would be fair and stuff D:

including demand, all store pets would go for quite more than a cookie.
Seeing that I'm offered an Cookie for two Orange Cerbs alone, demand is really high for certain store pets.

alright with 2 different opinions im quite confused. and a UR cookie for just 2 cerbs?! O.o wow!!

I agree with Silverstar on this.
A lot of the store pets are not on the main list, but instead on Advent List and some are on the September List.
But.. even if you include all other store pets, they are not list pets and would not entirely fill the gap for the UR Cookie. ^^