The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[kittycat396]

is this fair I'm not sure http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YmWYk50a5w

[EverGnar]

So rares-list wise the blue rat is higher than the light leopard, but I don't know about demand. What is fair?
the trade.
Thanks in advance!

I'm not great with demand, so you may want another opinion, but in my opinion I think it might be a tab bit unfair to the light leopard.

Still interested in a second opinion! c:

[kittycat396]

Hi. I need some advice on auction bids. Which of these is the best?
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 10

OMG 6 definitely!!

[Amberfly]

Hi. I need some advice on auction bids. Which of these is the best?
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 10

OMG 6 definitely!!

Thanks. Can I get another opinion, please?

[dorkasaurus]

Hi. I need some advice on auction bids. Which of these is the best?
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 10

OMG 6 definitely!!

Thanks. Can I get another opinion, please?

Actually I think 3 or 10 are the best.

[Ashki]

Hi. I need some advice on auction bids. Which of these is the best?
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 10

OMG 6 definitely!!

Thanks. Can I get another opinion, please?

10 is best.

[Amberfly]

Hi. I need some advice on auction bids. Which of these is the best?
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 6
Bid 7
Bid 8
Bid 10

Actually I think 3 or 10 are the best.

Thank you! Those are the two I was leaning towards as well, plus maybe #8. But the one with the pair of sitting cats threw me off--I know the worth on those gets harder to calculate because they were available for a long time.

Edit:

10 is best.

Thanks! I appreciate all the advice!

[The Dead]

Is this fair?
I thought it seemed roughly fair to me... Am I right?

[Firedancer77]

Demand doesn't really mean much as far as fairness goes. Unless it's a list pet, then it's demand is already taken into account.
Edit
Check this out.
It says, and this is a direct quote.

This list is not meant for silly very rares/rares as for example the august lion or the july lioness. Same goes for the shima longtail. Those pets do not belong on the rareslist.

This thread is about giving solid advice to people. Advice them on what would be good for their pets. what would be fair. Demand plays a huge role in that. Would you trade a BA for a dark leopard? probably not - you could get better. You know you could get better. Someone who doesn't know the demand, doesn't know they can get better comes here and gets the advice that a dark leo is fair without someone explaining that they can possible get more? They'll cut themselves in their fingers by accepting a trade that is 'fair' but not all they could've gotten.

It says this on the front page about demand..sorry to intrude, just trying to help out (: but including demand, yes it's unfair to your Lion

[/quote]

Not my lion, my offer on one. Thanks for the opinions.

[ToxicLama]

Fair?