The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Yunyi]

Is this fair? I'm not familiar with store pet values and how they translate to regular trades. :l

[Axolotl']

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m2CFgsVtJA
THANKS!

[maoisara]

Fair?

Unfair to them

Fair?

VERY unfair to top c;

Thanks! Any other opinions?

[swallows]

Fair?

Unfair to them

Fair?

VERY unfair to top c;

Thanks! Any other opinions?

please don't post the same thing twice on the same page, it is considered spam.

[Radioactive Wolf]

Fair?

Unfair to them

Fair?

VERY unfair to top c;

Thanks! Any other opinions?

Please do not post twice on the same page.
This has already been answered 3 times. Like everyone said before it is unfair to the top. ^^

[Shima Longtail]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m2CFgsVtJA
THANKS!

unfair to you. Just the warrior cat is enough. No need for overpay, unless you are willing.

[maoisara]

I didn't see that it was on the same page, sorry.

[Nicnova]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m2CFgsVtJA
THANKS!

unfair to you. Just the warrior cat is enough. No need for overpay, unless you are willing.

I disagree. The warrior cat they're offering is from July 2008, the cat they're asking for is from September 2009. That's over a year of difference. I'd say it looks pretty fair to me.

[Mysterious Banana]

Do you think the Red/Teal Butterbuns on the Advent list are easy to trade up?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m2CFgsVtJA
THANKS!

unfair to you. Just the warrior cat is enough. No need for overpay, unless you are willing.

I disagree. The warrior cat they're offering is from July 2008, the cat they're asking for is from September 2009. That's over a year of difference. I'd say it looks pretty fair to me.

its unfair to the bottom. The top cat was available for about a year and is therefore worth a mid-late 09 rare
That rat alone is fair