The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Inska]

Ok, thank you for the advice.

Is this one fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Gm1fuLxvnw

They're overpaying, though I'm not sure how much you could get with the starry calf at the moment.

I value it as a UR Aussie. Because the last time time I had some, I got UR Aussies.

Are you on the other side? If so, then a non-dog and around a blue tox needs to be added to the ice cat.

If not, then everyone values the new UR's differently, so it's up to each individual person. I just used a non-dog as an example since it's the what I've most commonly seen the new UR's go for ^^

They did go for UR aussies, but tend to go for lower at the moment.
But even if you value it at an UR aussie, the gap is only a non and a '09 UR dog.

[cheeryarver]

hello c:
I was wondering if this trade is fair?
thank you for any help~!

[DuckGoesRawr]

They did go for UR aussies, but tend to go for lower at the moment.
But even if you value it at an UR aussie, the gap is only a non and a '09 UR dog.

Like I said before, example of what I've seen them most commonly go for, I'm not sure were you think I'm saying they didn't go for aussies from. And yes, it's a non-dog and '09 UR, I forgot to half the sorbet and instead added the low main to the sorbet, my mistake

[broccoli_guardian]

Does the bottom side have to edit? If yes, how much? Uncommons or newer rares?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8H1_W4sqjQ

[QueenNyra]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nWmRmDAZTg
If not what should be added?

[DuckGoesRawr]

Does the bottom side have to edit? If yes, how much? Uncommons or newer rares?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8H1_W4sqjQ

It's unfair to them, you need to add though I'm not sure exactly what.

[broccoli_guardian]

Does the bottom side have to edit? If yes, how much? Uncommons or newer rares?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8H1_W4sqjQ

It's unfair to them, you need to add though I'm not sure exactly what.

Thank you. Second opinion or more advice?

[caesou]

hello c:
I was wondering if this trade is fair?
thank you for any help~!

Unfair to them. The store items are completely free, and anyone could get them. I'm not sure why they need them, but that doesn't matter.
The dogs should be worth more than the items, though, since the items are one of those things that are like "get-this-item set-for-free-but-only-get-them-once" thing. The entire set won't make up for it, either. The set has very low demand, and although you can only get the set once, they're completely useless.
I'd rather let you get a second opinion though, since I'm not too sure though.

[little sunshine]

hello c:
I was wondering if this trade is fair?
thank you for any help~!

Unfair to them. The store items are completely free, and anyone could get them. I'm not sure why they need them, but that doesn't matter.
The dogs should be worth more than the items, though, since the items are one of those things that are like "get-this-item set-for-free-but-only-get-them-once" thing. The entire set won't make up for it, either. The set has very low demand, and although you can only get the set once, they're completely useless.
I'd rather let you get a second opinion though, since I'm not too sure though.

Could not have put it better my self.

I agree.

[QueenNyra]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nWmRmDAZTg
If not what should be added?