The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Exoneration]

Is this fair?

How about the pps for the floppy blood? Including demand. I've never seen the pps before.

[little sunshine]

Is this fair?

How about the pps for the floppy blood? Including demand. I've never seen the pps before.

Unfair to you. I pretty sure thats a normal very rare.

[Exoneration]

Is this fair?

How about the pps for the floppy blood? Including demand. I've never seen the pps before.

Unfair to you. I pretty sure thats a normal very rare.

I thought so. Then again, I'm not very versed with list just yet. Thanks!

[reinbeaver]

is this a fair trade? link
i'm not sure how much my pet and their pet's worth.

Very unfair to you!

Agreed, very unfair.

Thank you!

[Exoneration]

I have another one..

My goal is to get the white malk Dragon. One tier above the floppy and two above my red rose. Would this be agood step in that direction?

[Kittyears]

Fair?

[Inska]

Is this fair?

How about the pps for the floppy blood? Including demand. I've never seen the pps before.

Unfair to you, even when you remove the red rose, the PPS is only worth 2 late '09 rares, the blood dog is worth 6. It doesn't have extraordinary demand, it's just one of these pets who are rare enough that not everyone has them but not so rare that they're advertised, as the '09 valentines etc.

I don't need anyone telling me these are unfair, but what's better?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IHxpZ9Q05A
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eUqJv6mbKg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... T1hF29hQ2Q Out of the 3 what would you say?

K! Maybe one more or two before I go? (P.S. Thanks!)

Actually, I think number two if better because it has the main line of Warrior Cats including an Advent. A group like that I've seen go for OMGSRs before. The Apple is...an Apple and yes, our us a main list, but to be honest two would be more favorable demand wise.

Depends. You can get at least a low mainlists worth out of the apple, but that takes a lot of patience. If you're looking for easy trade fodder, the second is best.
Also, the only OMGSR anyone would trade for it is the dark heart rat, and that will probably end up at the same tier as the UR apple.

Hey, so I'm continuing my adventure to get a Line Tribal..
What could I add to this trade to make it more fair? xx

Honestly? A line tribal.
What you're offering is nowhere near the worth of the line tribal, it doesn't even cover the gap to the next lowest tier (RBM).
The Line tribal is worth about 200 '09 rares.

Hey is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fx4OAershw

Unfair to them.

Thanks in advance c:

+ =

'11 store pet + '11 store pet = '09 Feb VR

Looks fair, maybe a bit unfair to the store pets, as they are worth an early '09 rare each (sometimes go for even more) and the VR is only worth 2 late '09 rares.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=38348080&userid=651503&signature=Kw9NxrXK0Kvihth_xlSEmQ
Do you think I can get a raven dog with those pets? >~<
Is it fair??

Raven dog - No. Would probably be fair, but the demand is insane.
The trade is unfair to quantity, even with demand that's about the most I ever see them going for (middish advent).

Fair?

Unfair to you, they need to add a low main.

I have another one..

My goal is to get the white malk Dragon. One tier above the floppy and two above my red rose. Would this be agood step in that direction?

No. It's overpay list-wise, but the Floppy hasn't the best demand while the red rose has pretty good. Most people would prefer the red rose in a trade over the floppy, especially if trading a good demand september as the malk dragon.

[Exoneration]

I have another one..

My goal is to get the white malk Dragon. One tier above the floppy and two above my red rose. Would this be agood step in that direction?

No. It's overpay list-wise, but the Floppy hasn't the best demand while the red rose has pretty good. Most people would prefer the red rose in a trade over the floppy, especially if trading a good demand september as the malk dragon.

Alright, thank you.

[creativecause]

The demand for these are huge, so is this overpay for a Black horned bull calf?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aMd47EbFMA

[little sunshine]

The demand for these are huge, so is this overpay for a Black horned bull calf?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aMd47EbFMA

Unfair to you.